Barnaby's of Northbrook
Italian / Pizza • $$
Offers a variety of affordable, family-friendly dining options, focusing on thin-crust pizza and classic tavern fare.
Ranked #3 out of 13 Italian / Pizza restaurants in Northbrook
Also in the top 10 of 58 restaurants in Northbrook
thin crust pizza
#1 of 75 Pizzas in the area
Crispy, buttery cornmeal crust topped with generous, high-quality cheese and flavorful sauce makes this pizza a standout favorite.
sausage pizza
The sausage pizza features a unique, crunchy thin crust and flavorful sausage, though some found it underwhelming and reminiscent of frozen options.
pizza (all varieties)
Crispy cornmeal crust pizza with quality toppings, including whole slices of juicy pineapple, receives rave reviews for its unique flavor.
Overall Flavor — Great
What’s a flavor score?Service — OK
Benny's notes: The crispy cornmeal-crust pizza and friendly service create a nostalgic dining experience that keeps families returning for generations.
Atmosphere
Noise Level — Average
Known for being...
Phone
(847) 498-3900Hours
Dietary Options
Features & Amenities
Reviews for Barnaby's of Northbrook
1,556 ratings, but no comments yet. Feed Benny yours below.
More restaurants in Northbrook
Francesco's Hole In the Wall
Italian · $$ · 1.0 mi
Top dish: butter cake · 98
Chicago Pizza Authority
Italian · 3.4 mi
Top dish: deep dish pizza · 92
Tony & Bruno's
Italian · $ · 1.7 mi
Top dish: new york style pizza · 88
Lou Malnati's Pizzeria
Italian · $$ · 1.9 mi
Top dish: the lou · 88
Napolita Pizzeria & Wine Bar, Northbrook
Italian · $$ · 2.0 mi
Top dish: appetizers (all varieties) · 89
Francesca's North
Italian · $$ · 1.8 mi
Top dish: tiramisu · 90
North Shore Bistro
Italian · 1.0 mi
Top dish: branzino · 86
Trattoria Oliverii
Italian · $$ · 2.0 mi
Top dish: appetizers (all varieties) · 85
Marisa's Pizza
Italian · $ · 4.8 mi
Top dish: new york style pizza · 88
Sarpino's Pizzeria Northbrook
Italian · $ · 2.0 mi
Top dish: pizza (all varieties) · 86
Domino's Pizza
Italian · $ · 1.6 mi
Top dish: pasta · 76
Rosati's Pizza
Italian · $$ · 3.0 mi
Top dish: pasta · 87