Hoosier Mama Pie Company
Dessert / Bakery • $$
Serves a variety of sweet and savory pies, including chicken pot pie and unique cream flavors, alongside coffee and breakfast options.
Ranked #7 out of 20 Dessert / Bakery restaurants in West Town, Chicago
chicken pot pie
The chicken pot pie features a flaky, buttery crust filled with tender chicken, fresh vegetables, and rich savory gravy.
banana cream pie
Banana cream pie features a buttery, flaky crust, thick vanilla bean cream, and fresh banana slices, earning rave reviews.
chocolate cream pie
The chocolate cream pie features a fresh, flaky crust and a rich, creamy filling topped with homemade whipped cream.
key lime pie
The key lime pie impresses with its creamy, tart filling, fluffy meringue, and a deliciously flaky graham cracker crust.
Overall Flavor — Great
What’s a flavor score?Service — Good
Benny's notes: Standout pies like the banana cream and chicken pot pie, combined with friendly service and a charming atmosphere, make this spot a must-visit.
Atmosphere
Noise Level — Average
Known for being...
Phone
(312) 243-4846Hours
Dietary Options
Features & Amenities
Reviews for Hoosier Mama Pie Company
1,521 ratings, but no comments yet. Feed Benny yours below.
More restaurants in West Town, Chicago
ECBG Cake Studio
Dessert · 0.6 mi
Top dish: wedding cake · 100
Paulo Gelato & Chocolate
Dessert · $$ · 0.7 mi
Top dish: pistachio gelato · 96
Jeni's Splendid Ice Creams
Dessert · $$ · 0.9 mi
Top dish: brown butter almond brittle · 97
Flourish Cake Design
Dessert · 0.3 mi
Top dish: cakes (all varieties) · 100
Blisspoint Bakery
Dessert · 0.5 mi
Top dish: cakes (all varieties) · 100
Reina's Cakes
Dessert · 1.3 mi
Top dish: cakes (all varieties) · 96
SUGOi Sweets
Dessert · 0.2 mi
Top dish: bonbons · 95
Butterfly Cookies LLC
Dessert · 0.1 mi
Top dish: cookies · 92
Bake
Dessert · $ · 1.3 mi
Top dish: croissants (all varieties) · 95
Eli’s Ark
Dessert · 1.0 mi
Top dish: ice cream · 88
Pie, Pie My Darling
Dessert · $$ · 1.3 mi
Top dish: cookies (all varieties) · 97
Black Dog Gelato
Dessert · $$ · 0.5 mi
Top dish: goat cheese caramel cashew gelato · 91