Potbelly
American • $
Serves a variety of sandwiches, salads, and milkshakes in a casual dining environment with both in-person and online ordering options.
Ranked #21 out of 22 American restaurants in Oak Park
soups
Soups were often cold, poorly prepared, and sometimes contained foreign objects, leading to widespread disappointment among customers.
sandwiches (all varieties)
Dry, poorly made sandwiches with missing ingredients, burnt edges, and rude service left many feeling disappointed and frustrated.
milkshakes
The milkshakes were criticized for being too milky, lacking flavor, and often served with stale toppings or incorrect orders.
Overall Flavor — Low
What’s a flavor score?Service — Poor
Benny's notes: Despite occasional positive experiences, frequent reports of poor service, long wait times, and incorrect orders overshadow the quality of the food.
Atmosphere
Noise Level — Very Loud
Known for being...
Phone
(708) 386-1395Hours
Dietary Options
Features & Amenities
Reviews for Potbelly
244 ratings, but no comments yet. Feed Benny yours below.
More restaurants in Oak Park
The Onion Roll
American · $$ · 1.4 mi
Top dish: lox · 90
Wings Galore
American · 1.2 mi
Top dish: wings · 86
Pete's Red Hots
American · $$ · 1.9 mi
Top dish: italian beef sandwich · 91
Mickey's Gyros & Ribs
American · $ · 0.2 mi
Top dish: big mickey · 89
PassionEats Express
American · 1.4 mi
Top dish: turkey chops · 87
FARE
American · 0.1 mi
Top dish: salmon · 84
Poor Phil's Bar and Grill
American · $$ · 0.2 mi
Top dish: blackened catfish po'boy · 86
Michael's Beef House
American · $ · 1.4 mi
Top dish: italian beef sandwich · 86
Chicago's Home of Chicken & Waffles
American · $$ · 1.0 mi
Top dish: desserts (all varieties) · 88
Wing Snob
American · 1.4 mi
Top dish: wings (all varieties) · 89
Chicago Waffles Oak Park
American · 0.5 mi
Top dish: red velvet pancakes · 88
George's Family Restaurant
American · $$ · 0.5 mi
Top dish: skillets (all varieties) · 85