Best Arepas in South Lawndale, Chicago
The 10 top-rated arepas in South Lawndale, Chicago, ranked by flavor score.
The top choice is gorditas at Los Olivos (3400 W 31st St), with a flavor score of 87 out of 100 from 17 diner ratings. Flavor scores come from what real diners say in their reviews. Last updated August 27, 2026. How flavor scores work →
Best Arepas across Chicago→- Ranked #1At Los Olivos3400 W 31st St
Handmade gorditas come stuffed with fresh ingredients like avocado and cheese, praised for their generous portions and amazing flavor.
- Ranked #2At Izalco Restaurant4377 W 26th St
Pupusas are praised for their authentic flavors, generous portions, and delicious fillings like chicharron and cheese.
- Ranked #3At Gordillas3759 W 26th St
Freshly made gorditas with flavorful fillings, complemented by a diverse salsa bar and rich, creamy beans, receive high praise.
- Ranked #4At La Cocina de Irma4224 W 31st St
- Ranked #5At Carniceria y Taqueria Aguascalientes3132 W 26th St
Homemade gorditas filled with a variety of meats are praised for their deliciousness and generous portions, especially with handmade tortillas.
- Ranked #6At Taquizas Don Rafa3857 W 26th St
- Ranked #7At El Faro Restaurant3936 W 31st St
- Ranked #8At Food Market La Chiquita3555 W 26th St
The gorditas are overpriced, often lacking sufficient filling and flavor, while the quality has noticeably declined over the years.
- Ranked #9At Gordillas3759 W 26th St
- Ranked #10At Taqueria La Chiquita2637 S Pulaski Rd Unit B