Best Italian Beef Sandwich in Edgewater, Chicago
The 8 top-rated italian beef sandwich in Edgewater, Chicago, ranked by flavor score.
The top choice is patio beef at Patio Beef (6022 N Broadway), with a flavor score of 85 out of 100 from 12 diner ratings. Flavor scores come from what real diners say in their reviews. Last updated August 27, 2026. How flavor scores work →
Best Italian Beef Sandwich across Chicago→- Ranked #1At Patio Beef6022 N Broadway
Patio Beef is celebrated for its delicious Italian beef with hot and sweet peppers, alongside fresh, friendly service.
- Ranked #2At Patio Beef6022 N Broadway
The Italian beef sandwich is praised for its juicy meat, especially when dipped with hot peppers and served with flavorful gravy.
- Ranked #3At Burke's Public House5401 N Broadway
The Italian beef sandwich features hearty beef and flavorful aus jus, though some found it overpriced and inconsistent in quality.
- Ranked #4At Pizzeria Aroma5350 N Broadway
- Ranked #5At Gino's North1111 W Granville Ave
The Italian beef sandwich lacks giardiniera, often comes with insufficient toppings, and is overshadowed by better options nearby.
- Ranked #6At Primo Pizza5600 N Clark St
The Italian beef sandwich suffers from dryness, lack of flavor, and inconsistent quality, with some portions being burnt or cold.
- Ranked #7At Sam’s Chicken & Ribs-Edgewater1102 W Granville Ave
The Italian beef sandwich suffers from being small, poorly executed, and lacking flavor, leaving diners disappointed.
- Ranked #8At Petes Pizza and Bakehouse1100 W Granville
The Italian beef sandwich featured dry, thick slices of bland meat on stale bread, leaving many diners disappointed.