Best Mac & Cheese in Elmhurst, IL
The 8 top-rated mac & cheese in Elmhurst, IL, ranked by flavor score.
The top choice is mac and cheese at Pasta To Go (926 N York St Unit 1), with a flavor score of 81 out of 100 from 5 diner ratings. Flavor scores come from what real diners say in their reviews. Last updated August 27, 2026. How flavor scores work →
- Ranked #1At Pasta To Go926 N York St Unit 1
- Ranked #2At Panera Bread108 E North Ave
- Ranked #3At 100 South Chop House and Grill100 S York St
- Ranked #4At Fry the Coop (Elmhurst)623 W North Ave #7
Creamy mac and cheese receives praise for its flavor, though some find it inconsistent or not as good as before.
- Ranked #5At Firewater BBQ & Brew - Elmhurst, Illinois635 W North Ave
The mac and cheese often disappointed with bland, watery flavors and inconsistent texture, overshadowing the otherwise praised barbecue offerings.
- Ranked #6At 151 Kitchen | Bar151 N York St
The mac and cheese is often criticized for being bland, underwhelming, and not worth the price.
- Ranked #7At Golden Boy Barbecue551 S York St
The mac and cheese was criticized for being flavorless, hard from reheating, and not worth the high price.
- Ranked #8At Victory Meat and Seafood130 N York St