Best Mac & Cheese in Evanston, IL
The 11 top-rated mac & cheese in Evanston, IL, ranked by flavor score.
The top choice is mac and cheese at Soul & Smoke (1601 Payne St Ste C), with a flavor score of 87 out of 100 from 189 diner ratings. Flavor scores come from what real diners say in their reviews. Last updated August 27, 2026. How flavor scores work →
- Ranked #1At Soul & Smoke1601 Payne St Ste C
Mac and cheese is creamy, well-seasoned, and features perfectly cooked noodles that complement the barbecue dishes beautifully.
- Ranked #2At Panino's Pizzeria1968 Dempster St
- Ranked #3At Claire's Korner1827 Emerson St
Creamy, hot, and bubbly mac and cheese receives high praise for its rich flavor and generous portion sizes.
- Ranked #4At The Barn Steakhouse1016 Church St Rear
Creamy mac and cheese with a perfectly seasoned and charred crust receives high praise for its rich flavor and satisfying texture.
- Ranked #5At Hecky's Barbecue1902 Green Bay Rd
Mac and cheese is creamy and indulgent but some found it small in portion or lacking in flavor.
- Ranked #6At Prairie Moon1635 Chicago Ave
Mac and cheese features a strong cheesy flavor and decent texture, though some found it bland or reminiscent of frozen meals.
- Ranked #7At Lucky Platter514 Main St
The mac and cheese was often criticized for being bland, dry, and lacking the creamy texture expected, disappointing many diners.
- Ranked #8
- Ranked #9At Peckish Pig623 Howard St
- Ranked #10At Noodles and Company930 Church St
The mac and cheese suffers from dry pasta, insufficient cheese sauce, and occasional hair contamination, leaving many disappointed.