Best Italian & Pizza in New Lenox, IL
The 9 top-rated italian & pizza in New Lenox, IL, ranked by flavor score.
The top choice is Paisano’s Pizza & Restaurant (350 W Maple St), with a flavor score of 88 out of 100 from 716 diner ratings. Flavor scores come from what real diners say in their reviews, and only restaurants with at least 100 ratings are ranked. Last updated August 27, 2026. How flavor scores work →
- Ranked #1350 W Maple St
Serves a variety of Italian dishes, including pizza, pasta, and ribs, with options for dine-in and takeout.
- Ranked #21938 E Lincoln Hwy
Serves a variety of Italian dishes, including pasta, seafood, and chicken, with options for both dine-in and takeout.
- Ranked #32510 E Lincoln Hwy
Serves Chicago-style deep dish and thin crust pizza along with fresh salads and other Italian-American dishes.
- Ranked #41840 E Lincoln Hwy
Serves a variety of pizzas including deep dish, stuffed, and thin crust, along with salads and sandwiches.
- Ranked #5650 W Maple (Rt 30)
Serves a variety of pizzas including thin and deep dish options, along with a selection of appetizers and drinks.
- Ranked #613150 E Lincoln Hwy Suite 5 Ste 5
Serves a variety of pizzas, including specialty options, alongside chicken wings and sides for dine-in or delivery.
- Ranked #7108 W Illinois Hwy
Serves Italian cuisine with a focus on pizza, pasta, and classic dishes in a casual sports bar setting.
- Ranked #8525 E. Lincoln Highway
Offers a variety of pizzas, wings, and sides for dine-in and delivery with a focus on convenience.
- Ranked #9320 W Maple St
Serves a variety of pizzas, including thin crust and specialty options, along with salads and sandwiches.