Best Italian & Pizza in Evanston, IL
The 12 top-rated italian & pizza in Evanston, IL, ranked by flavor score.
The top choice is Campagnola (815 Chicago Ave), with a flavor score of 88 out of 100 from 793 diner ratings. Flavor scores come from what real diners say in their reviews, and only restaurants with at least 100 ratings are ranked. Last updated August 27, 2026. How flavor scores work →
- Ranked #1815 Chicago Ave
Serves elevated Italian cuisine with a focus on fresh ingredients and generous portions in a cozy atmosphere.
- Ranked #21307 Chicago Ave
Serves Detroit-style pizza with a variety of toppings, salads, and gluten-free options in a casual setting.
- Ranked #31571 Sherman Ave
Serves authentic Italian cuisine with a diverse menu featuring pasta, pizza, and a variety of appetizers and desserts.
- Ranked #41945 Central St
Serves a variety of pizzas, calzones, and Italian dishes in a spacious, casual setting.
- Ranked #51245 Chicago Ave
Serves a variety of wood-fired pizzas, salads, and unique cocktails in a spacious dining area.
- Ranked #61968 Dempster St
Offers a diverse selection of pizza styles, pasta dishes, and Italian specialties in a casual dining setting.
- Ranked #71850 Sherman Ave
Serves Chicago-style deep dish pizza, personal pizzas, and a variety of appetizers in a casual dining atmosphere.
- Ranked #8815 Noyes St
Serves a variety of Italian dishes including pasta, pizza, and traditional entrees at reasonable prices.
- Ranked #9706 Main St
Serves authentic Italian cuisine with a focus on pizzas, pastas, and desserts made from high-quality ingredients.
- Ranked #101001 Davis St
Serves New York-style pizza alongside a variety of Mexican dishes, sandwiches, and burgers in a casual setting.