First Slice Pie Cafe
Coffee Shop / Cafe • $
Serves a variety of pies alongside sandwiches, salads, and quiches in a casual dining environment.
Ranked #2 out of 16 Coffee Shop / Cafe restaurants in Edgewater, Chicago
Also ranked #3 of 20 cafes and bakeries in Edgewater, Chicago
chocolate peanut butter pie
Dense and rich chocolate peanut butter pie features a smooth filling, a crunchy chocolate crust, and crushed peanuts on top.
key lime pie
The key lime pie is praised for its perfect balance of tartness and sweetness, complemented by an amazing graham cracker crust.
blueberry cheesecake
The blueberry cheesecake is consistently praised for its delicious flavor and creamy texture, making it a favorite among many.
cherry pie
The cherry pie features a perfectly balanced sweet and tart filling with a flaky crust that keeps everyone coming back.
Overall Flavor — Great
What’s a flavor score?Service — Great
Benny's notes: The standout pies, particularly the French Silk and blueberry cheesecake, paired with friendly service, make this cafe a beloved community spot for casual lunch or dessert.
Atmosphere
Noise Level — Quiet
Known for being...
Phone
(773) 275-4297Hours
Dietary Options
Features & Amenities
Reviews for First Slice Pie Cafe
1,825 ratings, but no comments yet. Feed Benny yours below.
More restaurants in Edgewater, Chicago
Kyoto Black
Coffee Shop · 1.3 mi
Sauce & Bread Kitchen
Coffee Shop · $$ · 1.2 mi
Top dish: croissants (all varieties) · 98
A Taste of Heaven
Coffee Shop · $$ · 0.1 mi
Top dish: scones (all varieties) · 92
DMApothecary & Tea Shop
Coffee Shop · 0.5 mi
Ann Sather
Coffee Shop · 1.1 mi
Top dish: cinnamon rolls · 89
Metropolis Coffee Company
Coffee Shop · $$ · 1.2 mi
Top dish: pastries · 85
Kopi Cafe
Coffee Shop · 0.1 mi
Top dish: cakes (all varieties) · 88
The Understudy Coffee and Books
Coffee Shop · 0.2 mi
Top dish: pastries · 83
Loaves & Witches
Coffee Shop · $$ · 1.0 mi
Top dish: cakes (all varieties) · 93
The Coffee Studio
Coffee Shop · $ · 0.3 mi
Top dish: almond croissant · 84
Happy Monday Coffee Roasters
Coffee Shop · 0.5 mi
Top dish: donuts · 82
Rivers and Roads Cafe
Coffee Shop · $$ · 1.3 mi
Top dish: sandwiches (all varieties) · 90