Fisherman's Island
American
Serves a variety of seafood dishes including shrimp, crab legs, and tilapia, with options for dine-in or takeout.
Scored, not yet ranked. We’re still chewing on reviews for this one.
See how North Lawndale, Chicago ranks →shrimp
Shrimp served was often overcooked, mushy, or not fresh, leading to significant disappointment among patrons.
crab
Crab legs were often overcooked, dry, and poorly seasoned, with some reports of unclean food and hair present.
Overall Flavor — Low
What’s a flavor score?Service — Poor
Benny's notes: The seafood platters featuring jumbo shrimp and crab legs receive high marks for flavor, though service inconsistencies and food temperature have been noted.
Phone
(773) 826-1500Hours
Dietary Options
Features & Amenities
Reviews for Fisherman's Island
51 ratings, but no comments yet. Feed Benny yours below.
More restaurants in North Lawndale, Chicago
The Soul Food Lounge
American · $$$ · 0.9 mi
Top dish: grilled pound cake · 92
Dave's Red Hots
American · $ · 0.3 mi
Top dish: sandwiches (all varieties) · 90
Sunshine’s Place
American · 0.4 mi
Top dish: mac and cheese · 83
Crawford Sausage Co
American · $$ · 1.6 mi
Top dish: prasky · 85
Peoria Packing Butcher Shop
American · $ · 1.7 mi
Top dish: ribeye · 82
Barney’s New Life Health Foods
American · $$ · 0.1 mi
Soulé
American · 0.5 mi
Top dish: salmon and shrimp · 83
Jus Chick-Hen Inc
American · 0.8 mi
Top dish: chicken · 75
Chicago Wings
American · 1.4 mi
Top dish: wings · 79
Mama's Fried Chicken
Italian · 0.8 mi
Top dish: gym shoe fried rice · 86
Star Gyros
American · $$ · 0.2 mi
Top dish: desserts (all varieties) · 78
City gyros
American · 0.5 mi
Top dish: gyros · 78