Potbelly
American • $
Serves a variety of toasted sandwiches, soups, and shakes with customizable options in a casual dining environment.
Ranked #22 out of 28 American restaurants in Evanston
oatmeal chocolate chip cookies
Oatmeal chocolate chip cookies are praised for their chewy texture, crisp edges, and addictive flavor, often compared to homemade.
wreck sandwich
The Wreck sandwich, loaded with salami, roast beef, turkey, and Swiss cheese, is praised for its perfect toasting and delicious flavor.
milkshakes
The milkshakes, especially the Oreo and chocolate banana varieties, are praised for their rich flavors and delightful cookie garnish.
sandwiches (all varieties)
Hearty sandwiches with good flavors and variety receive praise, though some find them overpriced or experience order mistakes.
Overall Flavor — Mid
What’s a flavor score?Service — Good
Benny's notes: The warm sandwiches and friendly staff create a welcoming atmosphere, complemented by unique offerings like the Mexican street corn chicken sandwich and live music.
Atmosphere
Noise Level — Average
Known for being...
Phone
(847) 328-1800Hours
Dietary Options
Features & Amenities
Reviews for Potbelly
239 ratings, but no comments yet. Feed Benny yours below.
More restaurants in Evanston
Ali's Broast & Burgers
American · 1.8 mi
Top dish: zinger burger · 95
Smash & fry
American · 0.8 mi
Top dish: burgers · 87
Blind Faith Cafe
American · $$ · 0.3 mi
Top dish: peanut butter chocolate cake · 91
Soul & Smoke
American · $$ · 1.0 mi
Top dish: shrimp & grits · 90
The Barn Steakhouse
American · $$$ · 0.3 mi
Top dish: filet · 94
Ward Eight
American · $$ · 1.8 mi
Top dish: sandwiches · 87
Evanston Chicken Shack
American · $ · 0.5 mi
Top dish: fried chicken · 91
Sarkis Cafe
American · 2.7 mi
Top dish: bacon loretta · 95
Free Flow Kitchen
American · $$ · 1.0 mi
Top dish: salads · 77
Mensch's Deli
American · $$ · 0.1 mi
Top dish: banana french toast · 90
Bat 17
American · $$ · 0.3 mi
Top dish: tyler durden cheesesteak · 88
Buffalo Joe's
American · $$ · 0.2 mi
Top dish: hot wings · 88