Caprarius

Crowning the Greatest of All Tastes

Caprarius

Crowning the Greatest of All Tastes

Explore
Graze Reports
About
Merch
Terms
Privacy
@caprarius.app

© 2026 Caprarius. Crowning the Greatest of All Tastes.

Best Sandwiches in Evanston, IL — Caprarius

Best Sandwiches in Evanston, IL

Evanston, IL/
Sandwiches

Best Sandwiches in Evanston, IL

The 100 top-rated sandwiches in Evanston, IL, ranked by flavor score.

The top choice is sandwiches (all varieties) at Ovo Frito Cafe (1936 Maple Ave), with a flavor score of 96 out of 100 from 32 diner ratings. Flavor scores come from what real diners say in their reviews. Last updated August 27, 2026. How flavor scores work →

Ranked #1
sandwiches (all varieties)
At Ovo Frito Cafe1936 Maple Ave
Ranked #2
indonesian ginger bbq sandwich
At Soulwich1634 Orrington Ave
The Indonesian ginger BBQ sandwich features fresh, flavorful pork or seitan, crunchy vegetables, and a tangy ginger sauce on warm, crispy bread.
Ranked #3
arepas (all varieties)
At La Cocinita Restaurant Evanston521 Davis St
Delicious arepas are packed with flavorful fillings like brisket and feature a crispy exterior, making them a must-try.
Ranked #4
sandwiches (all varieties)
At Backlot Coffee2006 Central St
Savory sandwiches made fresh in-house, featuring delicious flavors like tomato jam, impress with their quality and taste.
Ranked #5
sandwiches (all varieties)
At Eggs With Benefits527 Davis St
Ranked #6
indonesian bbq pork sandwich
At Soulwich1634 Orrington Ave
Ranked #7
10q chicken sandwich
At 10Q Chicken816 Church St
The 10Q chicken sandwich features perfectly crispy chicken, a flavorful mayo aioli, and crunchy pickled radish on a soft brioche bun.
Ranked #8
philly cheesesteak
At Ali's Broast & Burgers955 W Howard St
The Philly cheesesteak features perfectly cooked steak with rich flavors, complemented by crispy fries that reviewers rave about.
Ranked #9
the monty
At Backlot Coffee2006 Central St
Ranked #10
chicken sandwich
At 10Q Chicken816 Church St
Juicy chicken with an incredible crispy crust, topped with flavorful sauces like garlic parmesan aioli, makes this sandwich a favorite.
Ranked #11
sandwiches (all varieties)
At 10Q Chicken816 Church St
The sandwiches are flavorful and juicy, complemented by crispy fries and delicious dipping sauces like garlic parm and togarashi aioli.
Ranked #12
breakfast sandwiches
At Sarkis Cafe2632 Gross Point Rd
Ranked #13
bco sandwich
At Bluestone1932 Central St
Ranked #14
pambazo
At Zentli1813 Dempster St
Ranked #15
tyler durden cheesesteak
At Bat 171735 Benson Ave
Ranked #16
chili buffalo chicken sandwich
At 10Q Chicken816 Church St
Ranked #17
sandwiches (all varieties)
At Soulwich1634 Orrington Ave
Unique sandwiches feature fresh, high-quality ingredients with vibrant flavors, complemented by delicious homemade chips and slaw.
Ranked #18
philly steak
At Ali's Broast & Burgers955 W Howard St
The Philly steak impresses with its delicious flavor, generous portions, and extra cheesy options, making it a favorite choice.
Ranked #19
shrimp po boy
At Lucky Platter514 Main St
Ranked #20
sandwiches
At Ward Eight629 Howard St
Ranked #21
sebastopol sandwich
At Bennison's Bakery1000 Davis St
Ranked #22
sandwiches (all varieties)
At Sarkis Cafe2632 Gross Point Rd
The sandwiches are praised for their generous portions, melted cheese, and addictive flavors, making them a local favorite.
Ranked #23
sandwiches (all varieties)
At DeSalvo's Pizza1945 Central St
The sandwiches are praised for their quality and freshness, with reviewers noting well-composed flavors and ingredients.
Ranked #24
sandwiches
At Trattoria Demi1571 Sherman Ave
The sandwiches feature quality baguette bread and fresh ingredients, earning praise for their great taste and satisfying portions.
Ranked #25
sandwiches (all varieties)
At Curt’s Café2922 Central St
The sandwiches are praised for being enjoyable and flavorful, with a strong commitment to community and support for at-risk teens.
Ranked #26
sandwiches (all varieties)
At Ali's Broast & Burgers955 W Howard St
Ranked #27
philly cheesesteak
At Fatzees1608 Emerson St
Tender, flavorful meat paired with perfectly balanced cheese on fresh bread makes this Philly cheesesteak a standout choice.
Ranked #28
wraps (all varieties)
At Curt’s Café2922 Central St
Ranked #29
sandwiches
At Inspired Indian Cooking914 Noyes Street
Delicious sandwiches feature unique spices and generous fillings, with options for vegan selections and warm, satisfying flavors.
Ranked #30
sandwiches (all varieties)
At Zentli1813 Dempster St
Ranked #31
chicken torta
At La Principal700 Main St
Ranked #32
sandwiches (all varieties)
At Habibi In Mediterranean Grill-Evanston825 Church St
Ranked #33
paneer fig sandwich
At Soulwich1634 Orrington Ave
The paneer fig sandwich features a delightful blend of salty cheese, sweet figs, and caramelized onions on fresh bread.
Ranked #34
tortas
At Ovo Frito Cafe1936 Maple Ave
Ranked #35
bagel sandwiches
At Berry Pike Cafe1100 Davis St
Steamed bagel sandwiches are praised for being light and fluffy, fully stacked with fresh ingredients and delicious flavors.
Ranked #36
sandwiches
At Firehouse Grill750 Chicago Ave
Ranked #37
bulgogi cheesesteak sandwich
At Stacked & Folded - Evanston824 Noyes St
Ranked #38
brisket arepas
At La Cocinita Restaurant Evanston521 Davis St
Ranked #39
sandwiches (all varieties)
At Frida's Breakfast and Lunch618 Church St
Ranked #40
bulgogi cheesesteak
At Stacked & Folded - Evanston824 Noyes St
The bulgogi cheesesteak features tender marinated ribeye, caramelized onions, and melted provolone on a fresh baguette, earning rave reviews.
Ranked #41
sandwiches (all varieties)
At Lucky Platter514 Main St
Ranked #42
sandwiches (all varieties)
At The Fat Shallot Evanston2902 Central St
Filling sandwiches with customizable options and a simple menu earn praise, along with delicious sides like highly-rated fries.
Ranked #43
breakfast sandwiches
At Backlot Coffee2006 Central St
Breakfast sandwiches feature delicious flavors with options like turkey sausage and bacon, praised for their freshness and taste.
Ranked #44
sandwiches
At Beit Shawarma1601 Simpson St
Ranked #45
corned beef reuben
At Mensch's Deli1608 Chicago Ave
Ranked #46
sandwiches (all varieties)
At Blind Faith Cafe525 Dempster St
Ranked #47
fried chicken sandwich
At Lucky Platter514 Main St
Ranked #48
falafel sandwich
At Habibi In Mediterranean Grill-Evanston825 Church St
The falafel sandwich features generous toppings like pickles, salad, and tahini sauce, all wrapped in soft pita, earning high praise.
Ranked #49
sunrise breakfast sandwich
At Berry Pike Cafe1100 Davis St
Ranked #50
sandwiches (all varieties)
At Prairie Moon1635 Chicago Ave
Sandwiches are praised for generous portions and great flavors, often enjoyed with tasty guacamole and chips.
Ranked #51
sandwiches (all varieties)
At Bennison's Bakery1000 Davis St
Crusty bread and quality Boarshead deli meat make the sandwiches delicious, with the roast beef on a pretzel bun being a standout.
Ranked #52
sandwiches
At Sher-Main Grill802 Main St Fl 1
Ranked #53
chili buffalo sandwich
At 10Q Chicken816 Church St
Ranked #54
sandwiches (all varieties)
At Bluestone1932 Central St
Wonderful sandwiches with fresh ingredients, including favorites like chicken pesto and pot roast, consistently impress with great flavors.
Ranked #55
sandwiches (all varieties)
At The Hoosier Mama Pie Company749 Chicago Ave
Delicious sandwiches feature fresh ingredients and satisfying flavors, praised alongside their amazing pies and friendly service.
Ranked #56
bbq sandwich
At Blind Faith Cafe525 Dempster St
Ranked #57
sandwiches (all varieties)
At Hecky's Barbecue1902 Green Bay Rd
Ranked #58
el pabellon arepas
At La Cocinita Restaurant Evanston521 Davis St
El Pabellon arepas feature tender brisket, black beans, sweet plantains, and queso fresco, praised for rich flavors and generous portions.
Ranked #59
chicken sandwich
At Evanston Chicken Shack1925 Ridge Ave
Ranked #60
sandwiches (all varieties)
At Berry Pike Cafe1100 Davis St
Delicious sandwiches made to order with great flavors, complemented by solid coffee and a cozy atmosphere.
Ranked #61
bagel breakfast sandwich
At Berry Pike Cafe1100 Davis St
Ranked #62
sandwiches (all varieties)
At Cross-Rhodes Restaurant913 Chicago Ave
Ranked #63
10q sandwich
At 10Q Chicken816 Church St
The 10Q sandwich features crispy panko-fried chicken, creamy togarashi mayo, and bright pickled radish on a fluffy brioche bun.
Ranked #64
sandwiches
At Gigio's1001 Davis St
Ranked #65
pulled pork sandwich
At Hecky's Barbecue1902 Green Bay Rd
Pulled pork sandwich features tender, smoky meat on a soft brioche bun, complemented by just the right amount of sauce.
Ranked #66
italian sub sandwich
At Potbelly630 Davis Street Ste LL3
Ranked #67
pambazo
At Frida's Breakfast and Lunch618 Church St
Ranked #68
turkey and brie sandwich
At Stacked & Folded - Evanston824 Noyes St
The turkey and brie sandwich features flavorful turkey, gooey brie, and crunchy apple on a choice of bread, praised for its deliciousness.
Ranked #69
sandwiches (all varieties)
At Stacked & Folded - Evanston824 Noyes St
The sandwiches feature unique flavors and fresh ingredients, earning praise for their deliciousness and satisfying portions.
Ranked #70
sandwiches (all varieties)
At NEW YOLKTOWN1571 Sherman Ave
Ranked #71
wreck sandwich
At Potbelly630 Davis Street Ste LL3
The Wreck sandwich, loaded with salami, roast beef, turkey, and Swiss cheese, is praised for its perfect toasting and delicious flavor.
Ranked #72
buffalo chicken sandwich
At The Fat Shallot Evanston2902 Central St
Buffalo chicken sandwich has great flavor and crispy texture, but some found it overly sauced and overpriced without sides.
Ranked #73
loretta sandwich
At Sarkis Cafe2632 Gross Point Rd
Ranked #74
sandwiches
At Button Bakery719 Main St
Ranked #75
egg sandwiches
At Eggs With Benefits527 Davis St
Ranked #76
tortas
At The Supreme Burrito #1843 Dodge Ave
Tender, juicy meat in the tortas pairs perfectly with fresh veggies and delicious avocado on soft, flavorful bread.
Ranked #77
sandwiches (all varieties)
At Fatzees1608 Emerson St
Ranked #78
pot roast sandwich
At Bluestone1932 Central St
Ranked #79
pastrami sandwich
At Mensch's Deli1608 Chicago Ave
The pastrami sandwich features flavorful, house-smoked meat on light rye, praised for its tenderness and smoky richness.
Ranked #80
breakfast sandwiches
At Berry Pike Cafe1100 Davis St
Incredible breakfast sandwiches with fresh ingredients, customizable options, and great bagels earn high praise for their delicious flavors.
Ranked #81
sandwiches (all varieties)
At elephant + vine719 Church St
Ranked #82
bbq seitan sandwich
At Blind Faith Cafe525 Dempster St
The BBQ seitan sandwich is praised for its flavor and generous portions, though some found the texture tough and the bun dry.
Ranked #83
chicken sandwich
At elephant + vine719 Church St
Ranked #84
sandwiches (all varieties)
At Bat 171735 Benson Ave
Enormous sandwiches with top-notch ingredients and creative combinations receive high praise, making them a favorite among patrons.
Ranked #85
sandwiches (all varieties)
At Hewn Bakery1733 Central St
Artisan breads create delicious sandwiches that are fresh and flavorful, often praised for their quality and variety.
Ranked #86
cuban sandwich
At Stacked & Folded - Evanston824 Noyes St
Ranked #87
sandwiches (all varieties)
At La Principal700 Main St
Ranked #88
sandwiches (all varieties)
At Double Clutch Brewing2121 Ashland Ave
Ranked #89
grilled cheese
At The Fat Shallot Evanston2902 Central St
The grilled cheese features melted Muenster, spinach, and caramelized onions on crunchy sourdough, praised for its delicious flavor and perfect pairing with tomato bisque.
Ranked #90
sandwiches
At Outdoor Cafe Evanston2012 Central St
Ranked #91
pulled pork sandwich
At Double Clutch Brewing2121 Ashland Ave
Ranked #92
biscuit sandwiches
At The Hoosier Mama Pie Company749 Chicago Ave
Ranked #93
sandwiches (all varieties)
At Mensch's Deli1608 Chicago Ave
Generous portions of flavorful meats in authentic sandwiches earn praise, complemented by delicious bagels and a welcoming deli atmosphere.
Ranked #94
buffalo chicken sandwich
At Buffalo Joe's812 Clark St
Ranked #95
philly steak
At Fatzees1608 Emerson St
Philly steak features fresh ingredients and good flavor, though some found it dry and lacking in seasoning or cheese.
Ranked #96
sandwiches
At Crepe O'Clock601 Dempster St
Ranked #97
wraps (all varieties)
At elephant + vine719 Church St
Wraps offer good flavor and variety, but some found them cold or lacking in quality compared to earlier visits.
Ranked #98
breakfast biscuit sandwich
At The Hoosier Mama Pie Company749 Chicago Ave
Ranked #99
breakfast sandwiches
At D&D Dogs825 Noyes St
Ranked #100
tuna sandwich
At Soulwich1634 Orrington Ave

Which one is the GOAT?

You can crown one per category, so choose wisely.

More in Evanston, IL

Appetizers Desserts Meat & Poultry Salads Lunch & Dinner Sides Soups Burgers Pastries Pizzas Comfort Food & Classics Teas Other Beverages Coffee Sushi - Rolls Lattes & Cappuccinos

Best Sandwiches in other cities

Chicago Issaquah Oak Park New Lenox Elmhurst Northbrook La Grange Oak Brook Hinsdale Brookfield Evergreen Park La Grange Park Western Springs Riverside Clarendon Hills