Best Arepas in Lower West Side, Chicago
The 8 top-rated arepas in Lower West Side, Chicago, ranked by flavor score.
The top choice is huarache at La Esperanza Restaurant Pilsen (1864 S Blue Island Ave), with a flavor score of 90 out of 100 from 5 diner ratings. Flavor scores come from what real diners say in their reviews. Last updated August 27, 2026. How flavor scores work →
Best Arepas across Chicago→- Ranked #1At La Esperanza Restaurant Pilsen1864 S Blue Island Ave
- Ranked #2At Taqueria Los Alamos2157 S Damen Ave
- Ranked #3At Taqueria El Mezquite1756 W 18th St
Perfectly cooked gorditas feature flavorful corn masa, delicious rajas con queso, and a nice kick from poblano peppers.
- Ranked #4At La Esperanza Restaurant Pilsen1864 S Blue Island Ave
- Ranked #5At Carnitas La Michoacana2049 W Cermak Rd
- Ranked #6At Coyotes Restaurant1451 W 18th St
- Ranked #7At Casa Cafe2025 S Western Ave
- Ranked #8At Taqueria Los Comales Pilsen1544 W 18th St
Gorditas are praised for their size and flavor, but some found them mushy or lacking texture, with inconsistent quality.