Best Burgers in Evergreen Park, IL
The 18 top-rated burgers in Evergreen Park, IL, ranked by flavor score.
The top choice is butter burger at Culver’s (9515 S Kedzie Ave), with a flavor score of 87 out of 100 from 45 diner ratings. Flavor scores come from what real diners say in their reviews. Last updated August 27, 2026. How flavor scores work →
- Ranked #1At Culver’s9515 S Kedzie Ave
Juicy and tasty butter burgers receive praise, though some report issues with cold, dried-out burgers and inconsistent quality.
- Ranked #2At Pappy’s3301 W 95th St
Juicy burgers with fresh ingredients and perfectly seasoned, crispy fries make for a satisfying meal at Pappy's.
- Ranked #3
- Ranked #4At Porter Cullens Irish Pub & Restaurant3541 W 99th St
Juicy burgers receive high praise for their flavor, with many noting the deliciousness and freshness of the ingredients.
- Ranked #5At Pappy’s3301 W 95th St
- Ranked #6At Culver’s9515 S Kedzie Ave
The burgers are praised for being fresh and tasty, with some noting excellent customer service and enjoyable shakes.
- Ranked #7At Culver’s9515 S Kedzie Ave
- Ranked #8At Tavern in the Green3422 W 95th St
Burgers are generally flavorful and well-cooked, but some found them overpriced and occasionally overcooked or lacking in wow factor.
- Ranked #9At Evergreen Social Whiskey & BoardGame Tavern2855 W 95th St
Burgers are praised for their great flavor and quality, but some found them too salty or experienced long wait times.
- Ranked #10At Culver’s9515 S Kedzie Ave
Cheeseburgers are praised for their fresh taste and deliciousness, but some find them greasy and messy with occasional burnt fries.