Best Cookies in Uptown, Chicago
The 11 top-rated cookies in Uptown, Chicago, ranked by flavor score.
The top choice is cookies at Lucila's Alfajores (Please call beforehand to buy directly from us. This location is a small commercial bakery (not a retail shop). 4527 #106, 4527 N Ravenswood Ave), with a flavor score of 87 out of 100 from 7 diner ratings. Flavor scores come from what real diners say in their reviews. Last updated August 27, 2026. How flavor scores work →
Best Cookies across Chicago→- Ranked #1At Lucila's AlfajoresPlease call beforehand to buy directly from us. This location is a small commercial bakery (not a retail shop). 4527 #106, 4527 N Ravenswood Ave
- Ranked #2At Everybody's Coffee935 W Wilson Ave
- Ranked #3At Macaron Bar Andersonville5152 N Clark St
- Ranked #4At La Pâtisserie P1050-52 W Argyle St
- Ranked #5At Klein's Bakery & Cafe (Buena Park)4155 N Broadway
Cookies have a bready texture and are not too sweet, but some find them disappointing and lacking flavor.
- Ranked #6At Everybody's Coffee935 W Wilson Ave
- Ranked #7At La Pâtisserie P1050-52 W Argyle St
Almond cookies are praised for their light, chewy texture and flavor, though some found them stale or too hard.
- Ranked #8At Emerald City Coffee1224 W Wilson Ave
- Ranked #9At Dollop Coffee Co.4181 N Clarendon Ave
- Ranked #10At La Colombe Coffee Workshop5158 N Clark St