Best Cookies in Hinsdale, IL
The 11 top-rated cookies in Hinsdale, IL, ranked by flavor score.
The top choice is cookies (all varieties) at Sweet Ali's Gluten Free Bakery - Hinsdale (13 W 1st St), with a flavor score of 92 out of 100 from 128 diner ratings. Flavor scores come from what real diners say in their reviews. Last updated August 27, 2026. How flavor scores work →
- Ranked #1At Sweet Ali's Gluten Free Bakery - Hinsdale13 W 1st St
Soft, delicious cookies that taste just as good as traditional ones, with flavors like chocolate chip and butter cookies.
- Ranked #2At Sweet Ali's Gluten Free Bakery - Hinsdale13 W 1st St
Chocolate chip cookies are praised for their soft, cake-like texture and generous chocolate chip distribution, making them a favorite treat.
- Ranked #3At Toni Patisserie & Cafe51 S Washington St
- Ranked #4
- Ranked #5At Toni Patisserie & Cafe51 S Washington St
The cookies are praised for their delicious flavors, generous size, and beautiful designs, making them perfect for sharing.
- Ranked #6At Toni Patisserie & Cafe51 S Washington St
Superb macarons feature a delightful crunch with flavorful fillings, especially the pistachio and raspberry, leaving a lasting impression.
- Ranked #7At Cafe La Fortuna46 Village Pl
- Ranked #8
- Ranked #9At Toni Patisserie & Cafe51 S Washington St
- Ranked #10