Best Cookies in Evanston, IL
The 24 top-rated cookies in Evanston, IL, ranked by flavor score.
The top choice is cookies (all varieties) at Crave Cookies - Evanston (809 Church St), with a flavor score of 94 out of 100 from 189 diner ratings. Flavor scores come from what real diners say in their reviews. Last updated August 27, 2026. How flavor scores work →
- Ranked #1At Crave Cookies - Evanston809 Church St
Fresh, soft, and flavorful cookies consistently receive high praise, making them a favorite in Evanston.
- Ranked #2At Tag's Bakery - Evanston2010 Central St
Toasted almonds, rich caramel, and a touch of dried cherry create a deliciously addictive Florentine cookie coated in milk chocolate.
- Ranked #3At Button Bakery719 Main St
Cookies are consistently praised for their delicious taste, with flavors like peanut butter and seasonal varieties delighting customers.
- Ranked #4At Button Bakery719 Main St
- Ranked #5At Tag's Bakery - Evanston2010 Central St
Soft and buttery cookies, especially the addictive Florentines, earn high praise for their melt-in-your-mouth texture and rich flavors.
- Ranked #6At Crave Cookies - Evanston809 Church St
Warm, gooey chocolate chip cookies with rich, chocolatey flavor receive high praise for their melt-in-the-mouth texture and freshness.
- Ranked #7At Foodstuffs2106 Central St
- Ranked #8At Tag's Bakery - Evanston2010 Central St
Smiley face cookies are praised for their soft texture, delightful chocolate frosting, and nostalgic appeal, making them a beloved treat.
- Ranked #9At Sweet Temptations Bake Shop607 Howard St
Assorted cookies are praised for their delicious taste, appealing appearance, and balanced sweetness, making them a favorite treat.
- Ranked #10At Colectivo Coffee Evanston716 Church St