Best American Restaurants in New City, Chicago
The 4 top-rated american restaurants in New City, Chicago, ranked by flavor score.
The top choice is S2 Grills - Halsted (5058 S Halsted St), with a flavor score of 68 out of 100 from 101 diner ratings. Flavor scores come from what real diners say in their reviews, and only restaurants with at least 100 ratings are ranked. Last updated August 27, 2026. How flavor scores work →
Best American Restaurants across Chicago→- Ranked #15058 S Halsted St
Serves a diverse menu featuring items like grilled salmon, catfish, and loaded baked potatoes in a casual dining setting.
- Ranked #21808 W 47th St
Serves fried chicken with various sides, including biscuits, mashed potatoes, and macaroni and cheese.
- Ranked #31356 W 47th St
Serves a variety of Louisiana-style fried chicken, sandwiches, and sides in a fast-casual setting.
- Ranked #4740 W Garfield Blvd
Serves fried chicken and fish alongside gizzards and sides in a fast-food dining style.
Scored, but not yet ranked
These 9 american restaurants in New City, Chicagohave a flavor score, but we haven't read 100 diner ratings for them yet. Listed A–Z.
- Not yet ranked4653 S Halsted St
Serves a variety of diner-style comfort food, including burgers, fries, and breakfast options at affordable prices.
- Not yet ranked1925 W 47th St
Serves classic diner fare including cheeseburgers, pancakes, and French toast in a nostalgic, 15-seat setting.
- Not yet ranked5102 S Racine Ave
Serves a variety of breakfast dishes, including pancakes, omelets, and sausage, in a casual diner setting.
- Not yet ranked4703 S Damen Ave
Serves a variety of seafood dishes and smash burgers, with options for both dine-in and takeout.
- Not yet ranked4158 S Ashland Ave
Serves a variety of fast food items including burgers, fries, and breakfast options in a quick-service format.
- Not yet ranked1454 W 47th St
Offers a variety of fast food items including burgers, fries, and breakfast meals with drive-thru and dine-in options.
- Not yet ranked1400 W 46th St
Offers a variety of vegan food options alongside a brewery and community-focused events in a sustainable space.
- Not yet ranked1509 W 47th St
Serves a variety of breakfast options, with a focus on pancakes and generous portions in a casual setting.
- Not yet ranked2042 W 47th St
Serves a variety of chicken wings with multiple flavor options and sides in a casual takeout setting.