Cinderella Sandwich & Custard Shop
American
Serves classic diner fare including cheeseburgers, pancakes, and French toast in a nostalgic, 15-seat setting.
Scored, not yet ranked. We’re still chewing on reviews for this one.
See how New City, Chicago ranks →Overall Flavor — Exceptional
What’s a flavor score?Service — Great
Benny's notes: Exceptional cheeseburgers, generous pancakes, and a warm atmosphere crafted by the beloved owner create a unique dining experience reminiscent of home.
Atmosphere
Known for being...
Phone
(773) 523-2266Hours
Reviews for Cinderella Sandwich & Custard Shop
5 ratings, but no comments yet. Feed Benny yours below.
Explore the rankings
More restaurants in New City, Chicago
Tom’s Place
American · $$ · 0.5 mi
Top dish: pancakes · 96
Lowcountry The Yards
American · 0.1 mi
Top dish: burgers (all varieties) · 94
The Plant
American · 0.7 mi
Top dish: pizza · 71
Joe's Grill
American · $ · 1.1 mi
Top dish: pancakes · 68
Big Ray's Grill
American · $ · 1.4 mi
Top dish: burgers · 76
S2 Grills - Halsted
Mexican · $$ · 1.5 mi
Top dish: short rib · 85
Church's Texas Chicken
American · 0.2 mi
Top dish: fried chicken · 72
Wingstop
American · 0.2 mi
Top dish: alitas · 63
Popeyes Louisiana Kitchen
American · $ · 0.7 mi
Top dish: chicken · 52
55 ST Harold's & fresh lemonade
American · 1.8 mi
Top dish: catfish · 59
McDonald's
American · $ · 0.8 mi
Top dish: french fries · 44
McDonald's
American · $ · 0.6 mi
Top dish: sandwiches · 47