Best Bakeries & Desserts in Evanston, IL
The 13 top-rated bakeries & desserts in Evanston, IL, ranked by flavor score.
The top choice is Cold Stone Creamery (1611 Sherman Ave), with a flavor score of 89 out of 100 from 122 diner ratings. Flavor scores come from what real diners say in their reviews, and only restaurants with at least 100 ratings are ranked. Last updated August 27, 2026. How flavor scores work →
- Ranked #11611 Sherman Ave
Serves a variety of ice cream flavors and desserts with attentive customer service.
- Ranked #21733 Central St
Serves a variety of artisan breads, pastries, and coffee with a focus on quality ingredients.
- Ranked #31301 Chicago Ave
Serves Argentinian gelato with a wide variety of unique flavors and options for dairy-free sorbets.
- Ranked #4749 Chicago Ave
Specializes in a variety of sweet and savory pies, including chicken pot pie and coconut cream pie, with both indoor and outdoor seating.
- Ranked #5809 Church St
Serves a variety of cookies and loaded sodas with monthly flavor changes and generous portion sizes.
- Ranked #61926 Central St
Specializes in a variety of pastries, including macarons, croissants, scones, and custom cakes, alongside coffee and breakfast options.
- Ranked #71000 Davis St
Offers a wide variety of freshly baked goods, including pastries, cakes, cookies, and seasonal specialties.
- Ranked #8719 Main St
Offers a variety of freshly baked goods including breads, pastries, pizzas, and cookies in a neighborhood bakery setting.
- Ranked #9600 Davis St
Serves traditional French pastries, macarons, quiches, and a selection of hot and cold beverages in a quaint setting.
- Ranked #102126 Central St
Serves a variety of freshly baked breads, scones, and sandwiches with an emphasis on quality ingredients.