Jimmy's Pizza Cafe
Italian / Pizza • $
Serves New York style pizza by the slice or whole pie, featuring a variety of unique toppings and options.
Ranked #1 out of 6 Italian / Pizza restaurants in Lincoln Square, Chicago
Also in the top 10 of 76 restaurants in Lincoln Square, Chicago
new york style pizza
#1 of 56 Pizzas in the area
Thin, crispy crust with a chewy texture, well-balanced sauce, and high-quality toppings make this New York-style pizza a favorite.
white pizza
#2 of 56 Pizzas in the area
The white pizza features a thin, crispy crust topped with creamy ricotta and garlic, impressing with its rich flavor.
beignets
Fluffy, pillowy beignets come generously dusted with powdered sugar and are best enjoyed warm with a delicious dipping sauce.
pepperoni pizza
Crispy, flavorful pepperoni atop a perfectly thin crust impresses with quality ingredients and generous slice sizes, reminiscent of classic New York pizza.
Overall Flavor — Great
What’s a flavor score?Service — Good
Benny's notes: Standout choices like Quattro Funghi Truffle and Chicken Tikka Masala pizzas, along with friendly service, make this a local favorite.
Atmosphere
Noise Level — Average
Known for being...
Phone
(773) 293-6992Hours
Dietary Options
Features & Amenities
Reviews for Jimmy's Pizza Cafe
1,365 ratings, but no comments yet. Feed Benny yours below.
More restaurants in Lincoln Square, Chicago
Caro Mio Italian Restaurant
Italian · $$ · 0.3 mi
Top dish: gnocchi · 91
Pizza Art Cafe
Italian · $$ · 0.4 mi
Top dish: crepes (all varieties) · 95
Capriccio: Espresso + Focaccia Sandwiches + Roman Pizza
Italian · 0.5 mi
Top dish: sandwiches (all varieties) · 89
Borelli's Pizzeria
Italian · $$ · 0.6 mi
Top dish: thin crust pizza · 84
Dimo's Pizza Lincoln Square
Italian · 0.4 mi
Top dish: mac and cheese pizza · 83