

The 56 top-rated pizzas in Lincoln Square, Chicago, ranked by flavor score.
The top choice is new york style pizza at Jimmy's Pizza Cafe (2434 W Montrose Ave), with a flavor score of 93 out of 100 from 146 diner ratings. Flavor scores come from what real diners say in their reviews. Last updated August 27, 2026. How flavor scores work →
Thin, crispy crust with a chewy texture, well-balanced sauce, and high-quality toppings make this New York-style pizza a favorite.
The white pizza features a thin, crispy crust topped with creamy ricotta and garlic, impressing with its rich flavor.
The pizza features fresh ingredients, light yet thick dough, and a flavorful sauce that many found delicious.
Crispy, flavorful pepperoni atop a perfectly thin crust impresses with quality ingredients and generous slice sizes, reminiscent of classic New York pizza.
The pizza features a crispy, thin crust with generous toppings, gooey cheese, and a tangy sauce that many love.
NYC style pizza features large, foldable slices with a crusty bottom, flavorful sauce, and just the right amount of grease.
The Bolognese pizza features a perfectly thin crust topped with savory meat sauce and just the right amount of cheese.
You can crown one per category, so choose wisely.