Best Italian & Pizza in Lincoln Square, Chicago
The 6 top-rated italian & pizza in Lincoln Square, Chicago, ranked by flavor score.
The top choice is Jimmy's Pizza Cafe (2434 W Montrose Ave), with a flavor score of 90 out of 100 from 1365 diner ratings. Flavor scores come from what real diners say in their reviews, and only restaurants with at least 100 ratings are ranked. Last updated August 27, 2026. How flavor scores work →
Best Italian & Pizza across Chicago→- Ranked #12434 W Montrose Ave
Serves New York style pizza by the slice or whole pie, featuring a variety of unique toppings and options.
- Ranked #24603 N Lincoln Ave
Serves authentic Italian cuisine with a focus on handmade pasta, generous portions, and BYOB dining.
- Ranked #34658 N Rockwell St
Offers a variety of wood-fired pizzas, salads, and pasta in a cozy, BYOB setting.
- Ranked #44771 N Lincoln Ave
Serves Roman-style pizza by the slice, fresh focaccia sandwiches, and high-quality espresso in a casual cafe setting.
- Ranked #52124 W Lawrence Ave
Serves thin-crust pizza alongside a limited menu of appetizers and pasta in a family-friendly atmosphere with live music.
- Ranked #64647 N Lincoln Ave
Offers a diverse pizza menu featuring unique toppings and a casual atmosphere suitable for families and groups.