Potbelly
American • $
Serves a variety of sandwiches, salads, and shakes with a focus on quick service and fresh ingredients.
Ranked #30 out of 32 American restaurants in Logan Square, Chicago
milkshakes
The milkshakes often disappoint with watery consistency, small portions, and overly sweet flavors, despite some positive remarks on taste.
sandwiches (all varieties)
Sandwiches often arrive incorrectly made, lacking toppings, and with inconsistent quality, overshadowing the occasional praise for taste and service.
salads
Salads often feature wilted, brown lettuce, missing ingredients like bacon and dressing, and disappointingly small portions for the price.
Overall Flavor — Low
What’s a flavor score?Service — Poor
Benny's notes: Friendly staff and quick service complement a menu featuring hearty sandwiches and rich shakes, though order accuracy can vary significantly.
Atmosphere
Noise Level — Average
Known for being...
Phone
(773) 489-2535Hours
Dietary Options
Features & Amenities
Reviews for Potbelly
212 ratings, but no comments yet. Feed Benny yours below.
More restaurants in Logan Square, Chicago
Penumbra
American · $$$ · 1.4 mi
Top dish: shadow shrimp · 94
The Whale
American · $$ · 0.9 mi
Top dish: fried chicken · 93
Gretel
American · $$ · 1.2 mi
Top dish: gretel burger · 91
The Art of Chicken
American · $$ · 0.9 mi
Top dish: grilled chicken · 94
Bang Bang Pie & Biscuits
American · $$ · 1.0 mi
Top dish: key lime pie · 89
Lula Cafe
American · $$ · 1.1 mi
Top dish: desserts (all varieties) · 90
Boulevard Bistro
American · 0.1 mi
Top dish: pancakes · 93
Stay Cafe
American · $$ · 0.9 mi
Top dish: breakfast potatoes · 94
Scofflaw
American · $$$ · 1.5 mi
Top dish: chocolate chip cookies · 90
The Leavitt Street Inn & Tavern
American · $$ · 0.6 mi
Top dish: smash burger · 92
Parson's Chicken & Fish (Logan Square)
American · $$ · 1.2 mi
Top dish: desserts (all varieties) · 88
Way Out
American · 1.5 mi
Top dish: burgers · 88