The 20 top-rated shakes & malts in Logan Square, Chicago, ranked by flavor score.
The top choice is milkshakes at Cherubs Cafe (2524 W Fullerton Ave), with a flavor score of 94 out of 100 from 35 diner ratings. Flavor scores come from what real diners say in their reviews. Last updated August 27, 2026. How flavor scores work →
The banana chocolate and peanut butter milkshakes are incredibly rich and flavorful, consistently praised for their amazing taste and generous portions.
The oatmeal milkshake is a standout favorite, praised for its sweet, cinnamony flavor and creamy texture.
Decadent milkshakes made with house-made ice cream, including unique flavors like coconut, coffee, and basil, receive rave reviews.
The oatmeal shake combines creamy horchata-like flavors with cinnamon and a smooth texture, leaving a lasting impression on all who try it.
Creamy and flavorful milkshakes in various varieties, especially chocolate and vanilla, receive high praise for their generous portions.
The churro milkshake, featuring soft churros and rich flavors, receives high praise for its deliciousness and creative combinations.
You can crown one per category, so choose wisely.