The Hoosier Mama Pie Company
Dessert / Bakery • $$
Specializes in a variety of sweet and savory pies, including chicken pot pie and coconut cream pie, with both indoor and outdoor seating.
Ranked #3 out of 13 Dessert / Bakery restaurants in Evanston
Also in the top 10 of 34 cafes and bakeries in Evanston
chicken pot pie
The chicken pot pie features a creamy filling with tender chicken, vegetables, and a flaky, buttery crust that delights everyone.
quiche
The quiche is praised for its creamy texture and fluffy consistency, with flavors like ham, manchego, and sweet potato.
passion fruit meringue pie
Passion fruit meringue pie impresses with its perfect balance of flavors, soft meringue, and not overly sweet taste.
Overall Flavor — Great
What’s a flavor score?Service — Good
Benny's notes: Standout offerings include their chicken pot pie and an array of sweet pies, complemented by friendly service and a bustling, inviting atmosphere.
Atmosphere
Noise Level — Average
Known for being...
Phone
(847) 868-8863Hours
Dietary Options
Features & Amenities
Reviews for The Hoosier Mama Pie Company
1,371 ratings, but no comments yet. Feed Benny yours below.
More restaurants in Evanston
Cold Stone Creamery
Dessert · 1.1 mi
Top dish: ice cream · 91
Hewn Bakery
Dessert · $ · 2.4 mi
Top dish: monkey bread · 91
FRÍO Gelato - Evanston
Argentine · $ · 0.7 mi
Top dish: ice cream (all varieties) · 87
Crave Cookies - Evanston
Dessert · 1.2 mi
Top dish: cookies (all varieties) · 94
Beth's Bake Shop
Dessert · 2.5 mi
Top dish: cakes (all varieties) · 90
Poplar Pastries
Dessert · 2.4 mi
Top dish: baked goods (all varieties) · 94
Bennison's Bakery
Dessert · $$ · 1.1 mi
Top dish: petit fours · 89
Button Bakery
Dessert · 0.2 mi
Top dish: scones (all varieties) · 93
Pâtisserie Coralie
Dessert · $ · 1.0 mi
Top dish: almond croissant · 90
Great Harvest Bread
Dessert · $$ · 2.6 mi
Top dish: wildcat scones · 88
Hartigan's Ice Cream Shoppe
Dessert · $ · 2.9 mi
Top dish: ice cream (all varieties) · 89
Sweet Temptations Bake Shop
Dessert · $ · 0.8 mi
Top dish: cakes (all varieties) · 92