Hartigan's Ice Cream Shoppe
Dessert / Bakery • $
Serves a wide variety of ice cream flavors, sundaes, and other treats in a classic ice cream parlor setting.
Ranked #11 out of 13 Dessert / Bakery restaurants in Evanston
Features the #2 of 20 Ice Cream / Shakes
ice cream (all varieties)
#2 of 20 Ice Cream / Shakes in the area
The ice cream features a wide variety of delicious flavors, generous portions, and a nostalgic, friendly atmosphere.
milkshakes
Creamy milkshakes come in numerous flavors like mint chocolate chip and blueberry waffle cone, praised for their freshness and generous portions.
Overall Flavor — Good
What’s a flavor score?Service — Good
Benny's notes: The nostalgic ambiance, friendly staff, and extensive selection of creamy ice cream flavors make this local favorite a must-visit on hot summer days.
Atmosphere
Noise Level — Average
Known for being...
Phone
(847) 491-1232Hours
Dietary Options
Features & Amenities
Reviews for Hartigan's Ice Cream Shoppe
240 ratings, but no comments yet. Feed Benny yours below.
More restaurants in Evanston
Cold Stone Creamery
Dessert · 2.1 mi
Top dish: ice cream · 91
Hewn Bakery
Dessert · $ · 0.9 mi
Top dish: monkey bread · 91
The Hoosier Mama Pie Company
Dessert · $$ · 2.9 mi
Top dish: chicken pot pie · 90
FRÍO Gelato - Evanston
Argentine · $ · 2.4 mi
Top dish: ice cream (all varieties) · 87
Crave Cookies - Evanston
Dessert · 2.0 mi
Top dish: cookies (all varieties) · 94
Beth's Bake Shop
Dessert · 0.8 mi
Top dish: cakes (all varieties) · 90
Poplar Pastries
Dessert · 0.9 mi
Top dish: baked goods (all varieties) · 94
Bennison's Bakery
Dessert · $$ · 2.0 mi
Top dish: petit fours · 89
Button Bakery
Dessert · 2.7 mi
Top dish: scones (all varieties) · 93
Pâtisserie Coralie
Dessert · $ · 2.2 mi
Top dish: almond croissant · 90
Great Harvest Bread
Dessert · $$ · 0.6 mi
Top dish: wildcat scones · 88
Sweet Temptations Bake Shop
Dessert · $ · 3.6 mi
Top dish: cakes (all varieties) · 92