Caprarius

Crowning the Greatest of All Tastes

Caprarius

Crowning the Greatest of All Tastes

Explore
Graze Reports
About
Merch
Terms
Privacy
@caprarius.app

© 2026 Caprarius. Crowning the Greatest of All Tastes.

Best Burritos in Evanston, IL — Caprarius

Best Burritos in Evanston, IL

Evanston, IL/
Burritos

Best Burritos in Evanston, IL

The 25 top-rated burritos in Evanston, IL, ranked by flavor score.

The top choice is al pastor burrito at Tomate Fresh Kitchen (914 Noyes St), with a flavor score of 88 out of 100 from 12 diner ratings. Flavor scores come from what real diners say in their reviews. Last updated August 27, 2026. How flavor scores work →

Ranked #1
al pastor burrito
At Tomate Fresh Kitchen914 Noyes St
The al pastor burrito is praised for its fresh ingredients, flavorful meat, and perfect tortilla texture, making it a standout choice.
Ranked #2
burritos (all varieties)
At DosBros Fresh Mexican Grill1629 Orrington Ave Unit A
Fresh ingredients, generous portions, and well-rolled burritos with flavorful toppings like red onion and cilantro make this spot a favorite.
Ranked #3
burritos (all varieties)
At Tomate Fresh Kitchen914 Noyes St
Generous portions of flavorful burritos with fresh ingredients, featuring options like spicy mushrooms and sweet potatoes, are highly praised.
Ranked #4
burritos (all varieties)
At The Supreme Burrito #1843 Dodge Ave
Huge burritos packed with fresh ingredients like chicken and chorizo receive high praise for their delicious flavors and satisfying portions.
Ranked #5
burrito bowl
At DosBros Fresh Mexican Grill1629 Orrington Ave Unit A
Ranked #6
supreme burrito
At The Supreme Burrito #1843 Dodge Ave
The supreme burrito features fresh ingredients, savory salsas, and flavorful guacamole, making it a must-try for burrito lovers.
Ranked #7
chicken tinga burrito
At Tomate Fresh Kitchen914 Noyes St
The chicken tinga burrito is praised for its flavorful filling, generous portion, and fresh ingredients, making it a favorite choice.
Ranked #8
tofu burrito
At Tomate Fresh Kitchen914 Noyes St
Ranked #9
sweet potato burrito
At Tomate Fresh Kitchen914 Noyes St
Ranked #10
cochinita pibil burrito
At Tomate Fresh Kitchen914 Noyes St
Ranked #11
carne asada burrito
At Tomate Fresh Kitchen914 Noyes St
The carne asada burrito features well-seasoned meat, flavorful rice, and a tasty red salsa that complements the dish perfectly.
Ranked #12
carne asada burrito
At The Supreme Burrito #1843 Dodge Ave
Ranked #13
al pastor burrito
At The Supreme Burrito #1843 Dodge Ave
Ranked #14
chicken burrito
At The Supreme Burrito #1843 Dodge Ave
Ranked #15
black bean burrito
At Tomate Fresh Kitchen914 Noyes St
Ranked #16
burritos
At Comida1928 Central St
The burritos are large with fresh ingredients and good flavor, but some found them lacking authenticity and too pricey.
Ranked #17
farmers burrito
At Frida's Breakfast and Lunch618 Church St
Ranked #18
chimichanga
At The Supreme Burrito #1843 Dodge Ave
Ranked #19
burritos (all varieties)
At Frida's Breakfast and Lunch618 Church St
Ranked #20
steak burrito
At The Supreme Burrito #1843 Dodge Ave
The steak burrito features flavorful meat and warm tortillas, but some found it too greasy, bland, or poorly wrapped.
Ranked #21
king burrito
At The Supreme Burrito #1843 Dodge Ave
Ranked #22
chicken burrito
At El Pueblito Mexican Grill #21805 Howard St
Ranked #23
burritos
At Famous Taco Burger2901 Central St
Ranked #24
burritos (all varieties)
At El Pueblito Mexican Grill #21805 Howard St
Burritos often arrived with hair, incorrect ingredients, and poor seasoning, leading to disappointing experiences despite some positive remarks on taste.
Ranked #25
steak burrito
At El Pueblito Mexican Grill #21805 Howard St
The steak burrito was criticized for being mostly fat, over-salted, and poorly prepared, leaving many unsatisfied with their meal.

Which one is the GOAT?

You can crown one per category, so choose wisely.

More in Evanston, IL

Appetizers Sandwiches Desserts Meat & Poultry Salads Lunch & Dinner Sides Soups Burgers Pastries Pizzas Comfort Food & Classics Teas Other Beverages Coffee Sushi - Rolls

Best Burritos in other cities

Chicago Issaquah Elmhurst New Lenox La Grange Oak Park Oak Brook Brookfield Evergreen Park