The 85 top-rated pizzas in Evanston, IL, ranked by flavor score.
The Detroit style pizza features a thick, crispy, buttery crust topped with fresh ingredients and a delicious cheese crust.
The Raccoon pizza features a perfect balance of sausage, pepperoni, goat cheese, caramelized onions, and a touch of hot honey.
Thin, crunchy crust topped with flavorful sauce and generous toppings makes DeSalvo's pizza a favorite among locals.
The pizza features a perfectly crunchy crust and unique toppings like sausage and peppers, praised for its delicious flavor.
Delicious pizza with fresh mozzarella pairs perfectly with the intimate atmosphere and exceptional acoustics of the venue.
Super crispy crust and tangy sauce make the pizza a standout, even for those who typically dislike pizza.
Crispy, homemade pizza features fresh toppings and a perfect blend of flavors, earning high praise from satisfied diners.
New York style pizza features a firm yet soft crust, balanced sauce, cheese, and toppings, earning high praise for its flavor.
The lamb sausage pizza features flavorful sausage on a crispy thin crust, complemented by fresh toppings and a delightful sauce.
Thin, crispy pizza crusts topped with generous, high-quality ingredients like wild mushrooms and arugula receive enthusiastic praise for their flavor.
The pizza features a flavorful crust with generous toppings, consistently praised for its great taste and satisfying portions.
Buttery crust with a flavorful tomato sauce and ample toppings makes this deep dish pizza a standout favorite.
Calzones are praised for their delicious flavors, generous fillings like sausage and green peppers, and customizable options.
The Lou features a buttery, crispy crust topped with sautéed spinach, mushrooms, and fresh tomatoes, delivering a satisfying deep-dish experience.
Detroit-style pizza features a crispy crust, flavorful sauce, and generous cheese, with popular toppings like chorizo and jalapeños.
The pizza features a tender crust, high-quality melted cheese, and flavorful toppings like spicy salami and perfectly fried peppers.
Crispy, extra thin crust pizza topped with flavorful sausage, green peppers, and mozzarella cheese earns high praise for its deliciousness.
The mushroom pizza impresses with its earthy sage, perfect trio of cheeses, and a light, crispy crust.
Thin, foldable crust with juicy, oily cheese and flavorful sauce makes this New York style pizza a local favorite.
The pizza features delicious sauce and quality ingredients, with many praising the thin crust and overall flavor.
Hand-tossed and tavern-style pizzas receive praise for their fresh ingredients, flavorful toppings, and satisfying crusts when served hot.
The calzones are praised for their generous portions, flavorful fillings, and delicious marinara sauce, making them a favorite among diners.
The prosciutto and arugula pizza is celebrated for its fresh arugula, thin crust, and delightful flavor combination.
Pizza features a crispy crust and flavorful toppings, but some found the sauce watery and service slow or inconsistent.
The Godfather pizza features a thick, crispy crust and generous toppings, though some found it too salty or dry.
Deep dish pizza features a crispy crust and flavorful sauce, though some found it overly saucy or lacking toppings.
Sarpino's offers tasty, affordable pizza with a diverse menu and fast delivery, though some pizzas arrive only warm.
Margherita pizza has fresh tomato sauce and basil, but suffers from inconsistent crust texture and occasional sogginess or coldness.
Pepperoni pizza features a crisp, buttery crust and flavorful sauce, though some found it too salty and pricey.
Deep dish pizza features a light, crispy crust with fresh ingredients, though some found it small and pricey.
Thin crust pizza offers a crunchy texture and fresh toppings, but some found it overly salty or inconsistently cooked.
The wild mushroom pizza features flavorful mushrooms and creamy bechamel, but some found it overpriced and lacking depth.
Margherita pizza features a fluffy crust and fresh ingredients, but some found it lacking in sauce and basil.
Sausage pizza features a thin, crispy crust with decent toppings, though some found it bland or overpriced for the portion size.
Pizza has decent flavor and fluffy crust, but many experienced cold deliveries and inconsistent quality, leading to mixed feelings.
Pizza features a crispy crust and fresh toppings, but many found it burnt, undercooked, or reminiscent of frozen varieties.
The thin crust pizza often suffers from sogginess, underbaked dough, and bland flavors, overshadowing its fresh ingredients and inventive toppings.