Best Pizzas in Hinsdale, IL
The 20 top-rated pizzas in Hinsdale, IL, ranked by flavor score.
The top choice is pizza at Brasi's Pizzeria (34 E Hinsdale Ave), with a flavor score of 93 out of 100 from 125 diner ratings. Flavor scores come from what real diners say in their reviews. Last updated August 27, 2026. How flavor scores work →
- Ranked #1At Brasi's Pizzeria34 E Hinsdale Ave
Thin, crispy crust topped with flavorful sauce, high-quality cheese, and fresh ingredients makes this pizza a standout favorite.
- Ranked #2At Altamura Pizza9 W 1st St
Thin crust pizza made with imported Italian ingredients receives high praise for its fresh flavors and unique topping combinations.
- Ranked #3At Altamura Pizza9 W 1st St
- Ranked #4At Giuliano's Pizza40 Village Pl
Deep dish pizza features a perfectly baked crust and rich flavors, earning praise as the best in the area.
- Ranked #5At Giuliano's Pizza40 Village Pl
Thin crust pizza is praised for its crispy texture, fresh ingredients, and flavorful sauce, making it a local favorite.
- Ranked #6At Altamura Pizza9 W 1st St
Authentic Italian pizza features a crispy crust, delicious homemade ingredients, and standout options like sausage and margherita.
- Ranked #7At DeNucci's Hinsdale8 E 1st St
New York style pizza features a thin, crispy crust with the perfect balance of cheese and sauce, earning high praise.
- Ranked #8At Altamura Pizza9 W 1st St
Crispy, thin crust topped with fresh mozzarella and basil creates a deliciously balanced Margherita pizza that impresses everyone.
- Ranked #9At Vistro Prime112 S Washington St
- Ranked #10At Fuller House35 E 1st St
The pizza features a satisfying flavor with a nice balance of toppings, making it a popular choice among patrons.