Best Italian Beef Sandwich in Humboldt Park, Chicago
The 7 top-rated italian beef sandwich in Humboldt Park, Chicago, ranked by flavor score.
The top choice is italian beef sandwich at New Best Sub (3334 W Chicago Ave), with a flavor score of 94 out of 100 from 162 diner ratings. Flavor scores come from what real diners say in their reviews. Last updated August 27, 2026. How flavor scores work →
Best Italian Beef Sandwich across Chicago→- Ranked #1At New Best Sub3334 W Chicago Ave
Tender Italian beef with flavorful secret sauce consistently impresses, making it a top choice for many reviewers.
- Ranked #2At Whale Fish & Chicken3600 W Chicago Ave
Italian beef sandwich is praised for its meaty size and flavor, but some found it dry and lacking seasoning.
- Ranked #3At Chillyeee Philly's and Beef's427 North Kedzie Ave
The Italian beef sandwich is well-dipped and flavorful for some, but others found it bland and dry with unseasoned peppers.
- Ranked #4At Nick's On North3323 W N Ave
The Italian beef sandwich often lacked flavor, with some describing it as generic and even causing stomach issues.
- Ranked #5At Best Sub3156 W Chicago Ave
- Ranked #6At Grand Sunny Submarine3952 W Grand Ave
- Ranked #7At Elliots Augusta Pizza & Grill4400 W Augusta Blvd