Best Mac & Cheese in Edgewater, Chicago
The 9 top-rated mac & cheese in Edgewater, Chicago, ranked by flavor score.
The top choice is mac and cheese at Little Bad Wolf (1541 W Bryn Mawr Ave), with a flavor score of 84 out of 100 from 39 diner ratings. Flavor scores come from what real diners say in their reviews. Last updated August 27, 2026. How flavor scores work →
Best Mac & Cheese across Chicago→- Ranked #1At Little Bad Wolf1541 W Bryn Mawr Ave
Creamy mac and cheese topped with green onions and bacon receives high praise for its rich and comforting flavor.
- Ranked #2At Lady Gregory's Irish Bar & Restaurant5260 N Clark St
Mac and cheese features cavatappi pasta and Irish cheddar, but some found it overly rich or too heavy on onions.
- Ranked #3At Lady Gregory's Irish Bar & Restaurant5260 N Clark St
Lobster mac and cheese features rich flavors with large lobster chunks and a cornbread crust, though some found it overpriced and inconsistent.
- Ranked #4At Big Jones5347 N Clark St
Mac and cheese is creamy and well-seasoned, but some found it overly crispy, lacking in cheesy sauce, or just average.
- Ranked #5At Alice & Friends' Vegan Kitchen5812 N Broadway
Mac and cheese is creamy and well-liked, though some found it lacking in cheese flavor or consistency.
- Ranked #6At Fireside Restaurant & Lounge5739 N Ravenswood Ave
The mac and cheese often disappoints with bland flavor, overcooked broccoli, and a lack of seasoning, despite some positive ingredients.
- Ranked #7At Porkchop Edgewater6341 N Broadway
The mac and cheese was criticized for being grainy, lacking flavor, and often served cold, disappointing many diners.
- Ranked #8At Fireside Restaurant & Lounge5739 N Ravenswood Ave
- Ranked #9At Popeyes Louisiana Kitchen6340 N Broadway St
The mac and cheese was often served cold, poorly prepared, or missing altogether, disappointing many who ordered it.