Best Italian & Pizza in Edgewater, Chicago
The 12 top-rated italian & pizza in Edgewater, Chicago, ranked by flavor score.
The top choice is Sfera Sicilian Street Food (5759 N Broadway), with a flavor score of 93 out of 100 from 863 diner ratings. Flavor scores come from what real diners say in their reviews, and only restaurants with at least 100 ratings are ranked. Last updated August 27, 2026. How flavor scores work →
Best Italian & Pizza across Chicago→- Ranked #15759 N Broadway
Serves authentic Sicilian street food including arancini, focaccia sandwiches, and various pastries in a small, casual setting.
- Ranked #26221 N Clark St
Serves deep dish and tavern style pizzas featuring a unique sourdough crust and a variety of fresh toppings.
- Ranked #35316 N Clark St
Serves a variety of Italian dishes including house-made pastas, seasonal specials, and a selection of wines in a casual dining atmosphere.
- Ranked #45959 N Broadway
Serves Italian cuisine with a diverse menu featuring dishes like chicken parmigiano, rigatoni, and handmade focaccia.
- Ranked #55343 N Clark St
Serves a diverse menu of classic Italian dishes, including seafood pasta, veal parmigiana, and homemade desserts.
- Ranked #65457 N Clark St
Serves New York-style pizza by the slice along with a variety of appetizers and a spacious outdoor patio.
- Ranked #75350 N Broadway
Serves a variety of thin crust pizzas, pasta dishes, and sandwiches, with options for dine-in or delivery.
- Ranked #81100 W Granville
Specializes in oversized pizza slices, daily specials, and a variety of Italian dishes in a casual dining setting.
- Ranked #91111 W Granville Ave
Serves a variety of pizzas, including thin crust and deep dish, alongside a selection of appetizers and drinks.
- Ranked #101512 W Berwyn Ave
Serves a variety of pizzas and Italian dishes, with options for gluten-free and vegan diets.