Best Sandwiches in Clarendon Hills, IL
The 11 top-rated sandwiches in Clarendon Hills, IL, ranked by flavor score.
The top choice is sandwiches (all varieties) at Village Gourmet - Cafe & Catering (23 S Prospect Ave), with a flavor score of 88 out of 100 from 54 diner ratings. Flavor scores come from what real diners say in their reviews. Last updated August 27, 2026. How flavor scores work →
- Ranked #1At Village Gourmet - Cafe & Catering23 S Prospect Ave
Fresh ingredients and creative combinations shine in the delicious sandwiches, praised for their quality and unique flavors like praline mustard.
- Ranked #2At Country House241 55th St
The sandwiches, including unique options like bison, are consistently praised for their great taste and variety.
- Ranked #3At Country House241 55th St
The steak sandwich is tender and well-received, though some criticized the use of canned mushrooms and found it overpriced.
- Ranked #4At Country House241 55th St
The muffuletta features a delicious buttery bun filled with perfectly balanced meats, cheeses, and olive spread, earning high praise.
- Ranked #5At Country House241 55th St
- Ranked #6At Country House241 55th St
- Ranked #7At Country House241 55th St
The Reuben features tasty corned beef and generous portions, yet some found it small and lacking fresh ingredients.
- Ranked #8At Country House241 55th St
The Reuben sandwich features crispy, meaty layers with great 1000 Island dressing, but some found the corned beef lacking and portions small.
- Ranked #9At Country House241 55th St
- Ranked #10At Village Gourmet - Cafe & Catering23 S Prospect Ave