Best Shakes & Malts in Oak Park, IL
The 10 top-rated shakes & malts in Oak Park, IL, ranked by flavor score.
The top choice is milkshakes (all varieties) at Mickey's Gyros & Ribs (525 N Harlem Ave), with a flavor score of 84 out of 100 from 51 diner ratings. Flavor scores come from what real diners say in their reviews. Last updated August 27, 2026. How flavor scores work →
- Ranked #1At Mickey's Gyros & Ribs525 N Harlem Ave
Thick and creamy milkshakes, particularly the strawberry-pineapple variety with real fruit bits, receive high praise for their taste and consistency.
- Ranked #2At Michael's Beef House6747 West North Ave
- Ranked #3At Pete's Red Hots6346 Roosevelt Rd
- Ranked #4At Crepas Culichi1101 Lake St
The milkshakes impress with extravagant toppings like cotton candy and cookies, making them visually stunning and deliciously sweet.
- Ranked #5At Hole In the Wall Custard & Yogurt Shoppe901 S Oak Park Ave
- Ranked #6At Mickey's Gyros & Ribs525 N Harlem Ave
- Ranked #7At Mickey's Gyros & Ribs525 N Harlem Ave
- Ranked #8At Petersen's Ice Cream1100 Chicago Ave
- Ranked #9At Poor Phil's Bar and Grill139 S Marion St
- Ranked #10At Potbelly1100 Lake St Fl 1
The milkshakes were criticized for being too milky, lacking flavor, and often served with stale toppings or incorrect orders.