
Best Shakes & Malts in New Lenox, IL
The 10 top-rated shakes & malts in New Lenox, IL, ranked by flavor score.
- AJ's Hot Dogs, Subs & Gyros342 W Maple St
Hand-mixed milkshakes made with real ingredients receive high praise for their fantastic flavor and generous portions.
- 2Crepe N Brew336 W Maple St
The strawberry cheesecake milkshake topped with cheesecake and the Oreo shake received high praise for their delicious flavors.
- 3Portillo's New Lenox2306 E Lincoln Hwy
The chocolate cake shake is rich and indulgent, though some found it overly sweet and heavy on chocolate.
- 4Culver’s421 E Lincoln Hwy
Creamy milkshakes receive high praise for their rich flavor, with many enjoying the Concert Mixer variety.
- 5Five Guys2401 E Lincoln Hwy
Milkshakes like the Oreo crème and chocolate are praised for their flavor, but many complain about high prices and inconsistent service.
- 6Potbelly571 E Lincoln Hwy
Milkshakes have enjoyable flavors like Oreo and chocolate, but some experienced issues with spoilage and inconsistent portion sizes.
- 7Portillo's New Lenox2306 E Lincoln Hwy
The chocolate cake shake is a favorite for its rich flavor, but inconsistent quality and service issues frustrate many customers.
- 8McDonald's600 W Maple
- 9White Castle401 E Lincoln Hwy
The milkshakes often disappoint due to frequent unavailability, poor taste, and inconsistent quality, leaving many customers frustrated.
- 10Culver’s421 E Lincoln Hwy