Best Shakes & Malts in Evanston, IL
The 12 top-rated shakes & malts in Evanston, IL, ranked by flavor score.
- elephant + vine719 Church St
The milkshakes are super creamy and rich, with standout flavors like double chocolate, strawberries and cream, and salted caramel pretzel.
- 2Joy Yee Noodle533 Davis St
- 3Cold Stone Creamery1611 Sherman Ave
- 4Hartigan's Ice Cream Shoppe2909 Central St
Creamy milkshakes come in numerous flavors like mint chocolate chip and blueberry waffle cone, praised for their freshness and generous portions.
- 5Fatzees1608 Emerson St
- 6Potbelly630 Davis Street Ste LL3
The milkshakes, especially the Oreo and chocolate banana varieties, are praised for their rich flavors and delightful cookie garnish.
- 7Cupitol Coffee & Eatery (Evanston)812 Grove St
- 8Steak ’n Shake2209 Oakton St
Milkshakes are praised for their thick texture and flavors like Nutella and chocolate peanut butter, but complaints about long waits and inconsistent quality persist.
- 9D&D Dogs825 Noyes St
- 10Epic Burger1622 Sherman Ave
Milkshakes are overly sweet and lack flavor, with some reviewers finding them cloying and reminiscent of heavy cream.
- 11Steak ’n Shake2209 Oakton St
- 12FRÍO Gelato - Evanston1301 Chicago Ave