Best Ice Cream / Shakes in Evanston, IL
The 20 top-rated ice cream / shakes in Evanston, IL, ranked by flavor score.
The top choice is ice cream at Cold Stone Creamery (1611 Sherman Ave), with a flavor score of 91 out of 100 from 104 diner ratings. Flavor scores come from what real diners say in their reviews. Last updated August 27, 2026. How flavor scores work →
- Ranked #1At Cold Stone Creamery1611 Sherman Ave
Creamy and delicious ice cream, especially the fresh sugar-free vanilla with blueberry mix-ins, receives high praise for its quality.
- Ranked #2At Hartigan's Ice Cream Shoppe2909 Central St
The ice cream features a wide variety of delicious flavors, generous portions, and a nostalgic, friendly atmosphere.
- Ranked #3At FRÍO Gelato - Evanston1301 Chicago Ave
Unique flavors with a smooth texture and just the right sweetness make this ice cream a favorite among many.
- Ranked #4At FRÍO Gelato - Evanston1301 Chicago Ave
Creamy gelato with unique flavors like dulce de leche and avocado delights many, while portions offer a satisfying treat.
- Ranked #5At FRÍO Gelato - Evanston1301 Chicago Ave
- Ranked #6At FRÍO Gelato - Evanston1301 Chicago Ave
Cheese and honey gelato impresses with its creamy texture and balanced sweetness, reminiscent of cheesecake and fresh ingredients.
- Ranked #7At FRÍO Gelato - Evanston1301 Chicago Ave
- Ranked #8At FRÍO Gelato - Evanston1301 Chicago Ave
- Ranked #9At FRÍO Gelato - Evanston1301 Chicago Ave
Dulce de leche gelato impresses with its rich, creamy texture and authentic caramel flavor, making it a favorite among many.
- Ranked #10At FRÍO Gelato - Evanston1301 Chicago Ave