Best Pizzas in New City, Chicago
The 13 top-rated pizzas in New City, Chicago, ranked by flavor score.
The top choice is stuffed pizza at Positanos Pizza (4844 S Ashland Ave), with a flavor score of 84 out of 100 from 8 diner ratings. Flavor scores come from what real diners say in their reviews. Last updated August 27, 2026. How flavor scores work →
Best Pizzas across Chicago→- Ranked #1At Positanos Pizza4844 S Ashland Ave
- Ranked #2At Positanos Pizza4844 S Ashland Ave
The pizza features a flavorful sauce, perfectly cooked crust, and generous fresh toppings, making it a favorite for many.
- Ranked #3At Positanos Pizza4844 S Ashland Ave
- Ranked #4At Naples Pizza4601 S Ashland Ave
Thin crust pizza is praised for its flavor and quality, though some found it lacking in sauce and toppings.
- Ranked #5At El Sauz Taqueria2000 West 51st St
Pizza birria features generous meat and fresh lime, but some found it underwhelming and messy to handle.
- Ranked #6At The Plant1400 W 46th St
- Ranked #8At Pizza Hut2042 W 47th St
The pizza often arrives cold or undercooked, with issues like missing toppings, poor customer service, and small portion sizes.
- Ranked #9At Domino's Pizza4323 S Ashland Ave
The pizza often arrives cold, dry, and overcooked, with numerous complaints about poor hygiene and service issues.
- Ranked #10At Pizza Nova Express558 W 43rd St
The pizza is often undercooked, bland, or burnt, with many experiencing poor service and unprofessional staff.