Best Pizzas in Brookfield, IL
The 20 top-rated pizzas in Brookfield, IL, ranked by flavor score.
The top choice is pizza (all varieties) at Mama Barone’s-BROOKFIELD (9209 Broadway Ave), with a flavor score of 87 out of 100 from 184 diner ratings. Flavor scores come from what real diners say in their reviews. Last updated August 27, 2026. How flavor scores work →
- Ranked #1At Mama Barone’s-BROOKFIELD9209 Broadway Ave
Thin crust pizza garners praise for its toppings and price, but many criticize its lack of flavor and inconsistent quality.
- Ranked #2At Mama Barone’s-BROOKFIELD9209 Broadway Ave
- Ranked #3At Danny’s Italian Pizza & Beef9123 Ogden Ave
- Ranked #4At Sebastian's Ale and Whiskey House8900 Fairview Ave
- Ranked #5At Danny’s Italian Pizza & Beef9123 Ogden Ave
- Ranked #6At Mama Barone’s-BROOKFIELD9209 Broadway Ave
The thin crust pizza features great flavor and a crispy texture, with delicious toppings like homemade sausage and a fantastic sauce.
- Ranked #7At Danny’s Italian Pizza & Beef9123 Ogden Ave
Pizza has a decent flavor and good value, but many criticized the crust, cheese coverage, and overly sweet sauce.
- Ranked #8At Cordial Inn Bar and Video Slot Machines9207 W 31st St
- Ranked #9At Danny’s Italian Pizza & Beef9123 Ogden Ave
- Ranked #10At Paisans Pizzeria3720 Grand Blvd
Pizza often suffers from undercooked crust, overly sweet sauce, and inconsistent quality, though some appreciate the large portions and toppings.