New Lenox, IL / Pizzas Best Pizzas in New Lenox, IL The 32 top-rated pizzas in New Lenox, IL, ranked by flavor score.
The top choice is stuffed pizza at Nancy's Pizza New Lenox (1840 E Lincoln Hwy), with a flavor score of 88 out of 100 from 15 diner ratings. Flavor scores come from what real diners say in their reviews. Last updated August 27, 2026. How flavor scores work →
The stuffed pizza features a light crust filled with flavorful ingredients, earning praise for its amazing taste and quality.
Flavor score 88 out of 100, based on 15 ratings
Flavor score 87 out of 100, based on 4 ratings
Ranked # 3
Golden, buttery crust with zesty tomato sauce and generous cheese makes this deep dish pizza a top choice for many.
Flavor score 87 out of 100, based on 57 ratings
Ranked # 4
Deep dish pizza features a firm, crisp crust and generous mozzarella cheese, often praised for its delicious, slightly sweet sauce.
Flavor score 87 out of 100, based on 44 ratings
Flavor score 86 out of 100, based on 5 ratings
Ranked # 6
Nancy's pizza is praised for its generous toppings, excellent sauce, and consistently delicious flavors across both thin and stuffed crusts.
Flavor score 85 out of 100, based on 136 ratings
Flavor score 84 out of 100, based on 5 ratings
Ranked # 8
Thin crust pizza is consistently praised for its delicious flavor and has become a favorite for many loyal customers.
Flavor score 82 out of 100, based on 12 ratings
Ranked # 9
Thin crust pizza is praised for its crispy texture, delicious sausage and pepperoni, and a delightful garlic kick.
Flavor score 82 out of 100, based on 12 ratings
Flavor score 81 out of 100, based on 5 ratings
Ranked # 11
Thin crust pizza loaded with cheese and flavorful sausage earns praise for its delicious taste and satisfying portions.
Flavor score 81 out of 100, based on 573 ratings
Ranked # 12
Delicious pizza with quality ingredients and a variety of options, praised for its great flavor and cozy atmosphere.
Flavor score 80 out of 100, based on 181 ratings
Ranked # 13
At @ Rosati's Pizza| 108 W Illinois Hwy Delicious pizza with fresh ingredients and great flavors makes Rosati's a local favorite for families and gatherings.
Flavor score 79 out of 100, based on 121 ratings
Ranked # 14
Beggars Pizza impresses with its gluten-friendly crust and thick toppings, though some experienced undercooked crust on delivery orders.
Flavor score 78 out of 100, based on 12 ratings
Ranked # 15
Thin crust with flavorful sauce and fresh ingredients earns praise, but inconsistent cooking and order accuracy frustrate some customers.
Flavor score 77 out of 100, based on 179 ratings
Ranked # 16
At @ Joey’s Red Hots| Southwest Suburbs, 217 E Maple St Pizza offers decent flavor and good value, but some found it cold, bland, or lacking sufficient toppings.
Flavor score 77 out of 100, based on 161 ratings
Ranked # 17
The pizza features high-quality ingredients and great flavor, but many complained about undercooked crust, excessive cheese, and inconsistent delivery.
Flavor score 76 out of 100, based on 321 ratings
Ranked # 18
Deep dish pizza features a beloved crust and great flavor, but some experienced burnt edges and misleading portion sizes.
Flavor score 74 out of 100, based on 13 ratings
Flavor score 74 out of 100, based on 9 ratings
Flavor score 73 out of 100, based on 5 ratings
Ranked # 21
At @ Domino's Pizza| 13150 E Lincoln Hwy Suite 5 Ste 5 Pizza has a delicious garlicky crust and good flavor, but delivery issues and inconsistent service frustrated many customers.
Flavor score 71 out of 100, based on 96 ratings
Flavor score 69 out of 100, based on 8 ratings
Flavor score 68 out of 100, based on 7 ratings
Flavor score 57 out of 100, based on 5 ratings
Ranked # 25
The thin crust pizza suffers from a tough texture, excessive cheese, and bland flavor, leaving many disappointed.
Flavor score 57 out of 100, based on 13 ratings
Flavor score 57 out of 100, based on 4 ratings
Flavor score 57 out of 100, based on 8 ratings
Ranked # 28
At @ Pizza Hut| 525 E. Lincoln Highway The pizza was criticized for being cold, greasy, and lacking flavor, with toppings poorly distributed and excessive cinnamon.
Flavor score 56 out of 100, based on 99 ratings
Flavor score 52 out of 100, based on 6 ratings
Ranked # 30
Cold, bland, and overcooked, the thin crust pizza lacked sufficient sauce and toppings, leaving many diners dissatisfied.
Flavor score 51 out of 100, based on 19 ratings
Flavor score 50 out of 100, based on 8 ratings
Ranked # 32
At @ Taco Bell| 420 W Maple St The Mexican pizza was often soggy, poorly assembled, and made with dry beans, leading to a disappointing experience.
Flavor score 41 out of 100, based on 10 ratings
Show all 32 