
Best Pizzas in New Lenox, IL
The 32 top-rated pizzas in New Lenox, IL, ranked by flavor score.
- Nancy's Pizza New Lenox1840 E Lincoln Hwy
The stuffed pizza features a light crust filled with flavorful ingredients, earning praise for its amazing taste and quality.
- 2Beggars Pizza - New Lenox650 W Maple (Rt 30)
Deep dish pizza features a firm, crisp crust and generous mozzarella cheese, often praised for its delicious, slightly sweet sauce.
- 3Lou Malnati's Pizzeria2510 E Lincoln Hwy
Golden, buttery crust with zesty tomato sauce and generous cheese makes this deep dish pizza a top choice for many.
- 4Beggars Pizza - New Lenox650 W Maple (Rt 30)
- 5Lou Malnati's Pizzeria2510 E Lincoln Hwy
- 6Paisano’s Pizza & Restaurant350 W Maple St
- 7Nancy's Pizza New Lenox1840 E Lincoln Hwy
Nancy's pizza is praised for its generous toppings, excellent sauce, and consistently delicious flavors across both thin and stuffed crusts.
- 8Nancy's Pizza New Lenox1840 E Lincoln Hwy
Thin crust pizza is consistently praised for its delicious flavor and has become a favorite for many loyal customers.
- 9Paisano’s Pizza & Restaurant350 W Maple St
Thin crust pizza is praised for its crispy texture, delicious sausage and pepperoni, and a delightful garlic kick.
- 10Paisano’s Pizza & Restaurant350 W Maple St