Best Roasts & Stews in Evanston, IL
The 9 top-rated roasts & stews in Evanston, IL, ranked by flavor score.
The top choice is oxtail at Claire's Korner (1827 Emerson St), with a flavor score of 92 out of 100 from 45 diner ratings. Flavor scores come from what real diners say in their reviews. Last updated August 27, 2026. How flavor scores work →
- Ranked #1At Claire's Korner1827 Emerson St
Super tender oxtail stewed in a sweet and mildly spicy sauce, praised for its rich flavor and juicy texture.
- Ranked #2At Spice Restaurant1905 Church St Unit 2
Tender, flavorful oxtail served with rice and peas, praised for its comforting taste and generous portions.
- Ranked #3At Celtic Knot Public House2022 Central St
Shepherd's pie receives high praise for its authentic flavor and satisfying texture, making it a must-try dish.
- Ranked #4At Redz Belizean Restaurant337 Howard St
Oxtail is praised for its rich flavor and tenderness, though some found it undercooked and criticized the dry sides.
- Ranked #5At Taste of Jamaica Evanston741 Howard St
Tender and flavorful oxtail garners praise, but many feel the portion size is too small for the price.
- Ranked #6At Celtic Knot Public House2022 Central St
- Ranked #7At Kingston Grill1164 Dodge Ave
The oxtail dish was criticized for being mostly bones, lacking flavor, and having poor portion sizes, disappointing many diners.
- Ranked #8At Claire's Korner1827 Emerson St
- Ranked #9At LeTour Kitchen & Bar625 Davis Street Orrington Plaza