Insomnia Cookies
Dessert / Bakery
Serves a variety of freshly baked cookies and cookie-based desserts, available for walk-in and delivery orders.
Scored, not yet ranked. We’re still chewing on reviews for this one.
See how Evanston ranks →cookies
Cookies are praised for their fresh, chewy texture and great flavor, but some found them overpriced and inconsistent in size.
Overall Flavor — Mid
What’s a flavor score?Service — Great
Benny's notes: Consistently praised for their delicious cookies and friendly staff, though some customers report issues with order accuracy and value.
Reviews for Insomnia Cookies
36 ratings, but no comments yet. Feed Benny yours below.
Explore the rankings
More restaurants in Evanston
Cold Stone Creamery
Dessert · 0.1 mi
Top dish: ice cream · 91
Hewn Bakery
Dessert · $ · 1.3 mi
Top dish: monkey bread · 91
FRÍO Gelato - Evanston
Argentine · $ · 0.6 mi
Top dish: ice cream (all varieties) · 87
The Hoosier Mama Pie Company
Dessert · $$ · 1.2 mi
Top dish: chicken pot pie · 90
Crave Cookies - Evanston
Dessert · 0.1 mi
Top dish: cookies (all varieties) · 94
Beth's Bake Shop
Dessert · 1.4 mi
Top dish: cakes (all varieties) · 90
Bennison's Bakery
Dessert · $$ · 0.3 mi
Top dish: petit fours · 89
Poplar Pastries
Dessert · 1.3 mi
Top dish: baked goods (all varieties) · 94
Button Bakery
Dessert · 1.1 mi
Top dish: scones (all varieties) · 93
Pâtisserie Coralie
Dessert · $ · 0.2 mi
Top dish: almond croissant · 90
Great Harvest Bread
Dessert · $$ · 1.5 mi
Top dish: wildcat scones · 88
Hartigan's Ice Cream Shoppe
Dessert · $ · 2.0 mi
Top dish: ice cream (all varieties) · 89