Best Cookies in Lincoln Square, Chicago
The 18 top-rated cookies in Lincoln Square, Chicago, ranked by flavor score.
Best Cookies across Chicago→- Hilary's Cookies4917 N Lincoln Ave
Soft and chewy, Hilary's cookies are praised for their fresh flavors and quality ingredients, delighting both vegans and non-vegans alike.
- 2Hilary's Cookies4917 N Lincoln Ave
- 3Spoken Cafe1812 W Montrose Ave
- 4Amy's Candy Bar4704 N Damen Ave
- 5Bagel Miller Bagels4655 N Lincoln Ave
- 6Dorothy's Sweet Shoppe4925 N Lincoln Ave
- 7Lutz Bakery2458 W Montrose Ave
The cookies are praised for their delightful buttery flavor and beautiful presentation, making them popular for gifts and gatherings.
- 8Hilary's Cookies4917 N Lincoln Ave
- 9Lutz Bakery2458 W Montrose Ave
- 10Oromo Cafe Lincoln Square4703 N Lincoln Ave
- 11Bagel Miller Bagels4655 N Lincoln Ave
The chocolate chip cookies are praised for their crunchy texture, balanced sweetness, and high-quality ingredients that make them stand out.
- 12Del Sur Bakery & Cafe4639 N Damen Ave
- 13Hilary's Cookies4917 N Lincoln Ave
- 14The Perfect Cup4700 N Damen Ave
Cookies are tasty and reasonably priced, but the coffee often disappoints with inconsistent quality and burnt flavors.
- 15Vaca’s Creamery2324 W Giddings St
- 16Lutz Bakery2458 W Montrose Ave
- 17Sweet Moon1964 W Lawrence Ave
- 18Willow Café and Bistro4729 N Lincoln Ave