The 78 top-rated ice cream / shakes in West Town, Chicago, ranked by flavor score.
Brown butter almond brittle delights with its buttery flavor, crunchy almond bits, and perfect balance of sweetness in a creamy texture.
Creamy, rich pistachio gelato made with real Sicilian pistachios impresses with its smooth texture and balanced flavor.
Rich, creamy gelato with unique flavors like Mango Lassi and Burnt Butter Vanilla impresses with its freshness and smooth texture.
Creamy and unique flavors made from 100% real ingredients impress many, making it a favorite ice cream spot.
Wildberry lavender offers a creamy texture with sweet berry notes and a subtle hint of lavender, perfectly balanced and refreshing.
Unique and delicious ice cream flavors, including sweet potato with toasted marshmallow, paired with freshly made waffle cones, earn rave reviews.
Creamy vanilla ice cream layered with sweet-tart brambleberry jam and crunchy oat streusel creates a pie-like indulgence that delights.
Delicious homemade ice cream with unique flavors like chocolate swirl and mini peanut butter cups, praised for its freshness and quality.
Goat cheese cashew caramel combines sweet caramel with subtle goat cheese and crunchy cashews, creating a uniquely delicious flavor.
Creamy, flavorful ice cream with unique layered options like the Rainbow Cone delights visitors, who also appreciate the friendly service.
Rich, creamy ice cream bursting with flavor pairs perfectly with warm, fluffy waffles, making it a must-try dessert spot.
Creamy ice cream with unique flavors like olive oil and sweet corn impresses, while generous portions and rotating options delight.
Rich and creamy chocolate gelato impresses with deep cocoa flavor, reminiscent of fine chocolate mousse, and is made from fresh ingredients.
Wildberry lavender ice cream impresses with its creamy texture and balanced fruity floral notes, making it a standout favorite.
The trio gelato combines rich peanut butter, dulce de leche, and hazelnut flavors, praised for its creamy texture and balanced taste.
Darkest Chocolate offers a rich, intense flavor reminiscent of actual dark chocolate, perfectly complemented by freshly made waffle cones.
Rich and creamy ice cream with a fantastic variety of flavors, praised for its quality and deliciousness.
The goat cheese cashew caramel gelato impresses with its creamy texture and a delightful balance of tangy and sweet flavors.
Silky smooth gelato with unique flavors like goat cheese caramel and Mexican hot chocolate delights customers, making it a must-try.
Rich coffee flavor shines through in this creamy ice cream, perfectly complemented by the homemade waffle cone.
The matcha soft serve impresses with its deep flavor, creamy texture, and high-quality ingredients, making it a must-try treat.
Goat cheese caramel cashew gelato impresses with its smooth texture and unique flavor combination of sweet caramel and savory cheese.
Brambleberry crisp ice cream impresses with its creamy texture and unique flavor, complemented by freshly made waffle cones.
Lavender ice cream impresses with its soft, mild flavor and beautiful color, delighting those who appreciate unique ice cream options.
Dark chocolate ice cream impresses with its rich, intense flavor and creamy texture, perfectly paired with a crisp waffle cone.
The Original Rainbow Cone delights with its colorful layers of orange sherbet, pistachio, vanilla with cherries and walnuts, strawberry, and chocolate.
Salty caramel impresses with its perfect balance of sweet and salty flavors, making it a favorite among many.
Pistachio gelato stands out for its authentic flavor, creamy texture, and natural beige color, earning rave reviews from many.
Malted vanilla gelato impresses with its rich, creamy texture and is often described as one of the best flavors available.
Goat cheese caramel cashew gelato offers creamy richness and a unique flavor blend, though some find it overly rich or often unavailable.
Mexican Chocolate offers a spicy kick that some enjoy, but others find it too heavy or not rich enough.
Goat cheese gelato is creamy and unique, though some found it lacking in flavor or preferred other gelato shops.
Pistachio gelato is creamy and rich with real pistachio flavor, though some found it overly salty or pricey.
Warm cookies and good ice cream are highlights, but some found it overpriced and criticized the inconsistent service and delivery issues.
Salted peanut gelato is creamy and buttery with a smooth texture, though some found it less rich than expected.
Chocolate gelato is creamy and rich, but some found it too sweet or artificial, with limited flavor options available.
Strawberry balsamic gelato offers a mild sweetness and smooth texture, though some found it lacking in balsamic flavor.
Flavors like cantaloupe and blood orange impress, but some found prices high for portion sizes and faced availability issues.
Mexican hot chocolate gelato features a spicy kick and creamy texture, though some found it too rich or overly sweet.
The Mexican chocolate gelato is often criticized for being too spicy and lacking a diverse selection of flavors.
Ice cream was often freezer burnt, poorly scooped, and came with disappointing service, making for a frustrating experience.