Caprarius

Crowning the Greatest of All Tastes

Caprarius

Crowning the Greatest of All Tastes

Explore
Graze Reports
About
Merch
Terms
Privacy
@caprarius.app

© 2026 Caprarius. Crowning the Greatest of All Tastes.

Best Ice Cream / Shakes in Northbrook, IL — Caprarius

Best Ice Cream / Shakes in Northbrook, IL

Explore/
Northbrook, IL

Best Ice Cream / Shakes in Northbrook, IL

The 25 top-rated ice cream / shakes in Northbrook, IL, ranked by flavor score.

black cherry chocolate chip ice cream
Graeter's Ice Cream1347 Shermer Rd
2
s'mores
Graeter's Ice Cream1347 Shermer Rd
3
s'mores ice cream
Graeter's Ice Cream1347 Shermer Rd
4
black raspberry chip ice cream
Graeter's Ice Cream1347 Shermer Rd
5
ice cream (all varieties)
Graeter's Ice Cream1347 Shermer Rd
Creamy and consistently delicious ice cream with unique flavors and huge chunks of chocolate that keep customers coming back.
6
raspberry sorbet
Graeter's Ice Cream1347 Shermer Rd
7
black raspberry chocolate chip ice cream
Graeter's Ice Cream1347 Shermer Rd
8
ice cream sundae
Graeter's Ice Cream1347 Shermer Rd
Rich chocolate and seasonal flavors create delightful sundaes, praised for their quality and generous portions at a great price.
9
mint chip ice cream
Graeter's Ice Cream1347 Shermer Rd
10
black cherry chocolate chip
Graeter's Ice Cream1347 Shermer Rd
11
bourbon pecan ice cream
Graeter's Ice Cream1347 Shermer Rd
12
chocolate chip ice cream
Graeter's Ice Cream1347 Shermer Rd
13
black raspberry chocolate chip
Graeter's Ice Cream1347 Shermer Rd
14
hot fudge sundae
Graeter's Ice Cream1347 Shermer Rd
15
black raspberry ice cream
Graeter's Ice Cream1347 Shermer Rd
16
black raspberry chip
Graeter's Ice Cream1347 Shermer Rd
Black Raspberry Chip ice cream is praised for its delicious flavor and refreshing quality, making it a favorite choice.
17
peach ice cream
Graeter's Ice Cream1347 Shermer Rd
Peach ice cream is praised for its fresh, creamy texture and generous chunks of real peaches, making it a favorite.
18
sorbet
Graeter's Ice Cream1347 Shermer Rd
19
ice cream
Baskin-Robbins1346 Shermer Rd
The ice cream suffers from inconsistency in quality, with complaints about small portions, freezer burn taste, and rude service.
20
soft serve
Dairy Queen2770 Dundee Rd
21
ice cream
Crumbl984 Willow Rd Ste C
22
ice cream (all varieties)
Dairy Queen2770 Dundee Rd
The ice cream is decent, but poor service, long waits, and cleanliness issues significantly detract from the overall experience.
23
ice cream cone
Dairy Queen2770 Dundee Rd
The ice cream cone was poorly portioned, unsanitary, and took an unreasonably long time to be served.
24
blizzards
Dairy Queen2770 Dundee Rd
Thin, runny Blizzards with insufficient toppings and poor service left many feeling disappointed and frustrated with their experience.
25
cone
Dairy Queen2770 Dundee Rd

Which one is the GOAT?

You can crown one per category, so choose wisely.

More in Northbrook, IL

Appetizers Sandwiches Meat & Poultry Salads Desserts Lunch & Dinner Sides Soups Pizzas Burgers Comfort Food & Classics Seafood Steaks Pastas American Chinese Classics Coffee

Best Ice Cream / Shakes in other cities

Chicago Oak Park Evanston Elmhurst La Grange Oak Brook Evergreen Park