Best Pizzas in South Lawndale, Chicago
The 10 top-rated pizzas in South Lawndale, Chicago, ranked by flavor score.
The top choice is pizza at Naty's Pizza 26st (3849 W 26th St #3810), with a flavor score of 82 out of 100 from 95 diner ratings. Flavor scores come from what real diners say in their reviews. Last updated August 27, 2026. How flavor scores work →
Best Pizzas across Chicago→- Ranked #1At Naty's Pizza 26st3849 W 26th St #3810
Thick and thin crust options are praised for their gooey cheese and fresh flavors, making it a favorite for many.
- Ranked #2At Dennis B&K3806 W 26th St
Crispy crust and gooey cheese create a delicious pizza experience, praised for its nostalgic flavors and great prices.
- Ranked #3At Celis Pizzeria2605 S Kostner Ave
Pizza is praised for its good flavor and affordability, but many criticize the rude customer service and inconsistent pricing.
- Ranked #4At Home Run Inn Pizza4254 W 31st St
- Ranked #5At Pizza Tango2859 W Cermak Rd
Thin crust pizza with great sauce and fresh toppings is praised, but some experienced burnt crust and poor service.
- Ranked #6At Guerrero's Pizza2024 S California Ave
Pizza has a soft crust and fresh cheese, but some found it greasy or undercooked with inconsistent quality.
- Ranked #7At Home Run Inn Pizza4254 W 31st St
The pizza features a buttery crust and tasty toppings, but inconsistencies in cooking and flavor left some disappointed.
- Ranked #8At Denni's Pizza3257 W 26th St
Pizza is fresh and affordable with good flavor, but some found it dry and reminiscent of school lunches.
- Ranked #9At Pizza Nova3704 W 26th St
The pizza often arrives with incorrect toppings, cold sides, and inconsistent quality, leading to disappointing experiences for many.
- Ranked #10At Home Run Inn Pizza4254 W 31st St