
Best Seafood in Evanston, IL
The 44 top-rated seafood in Evanston, IL, ranked by flavor score.
- Celtic Knot Public House2022 Central St
Crispy fish with light breading and excellent cod, paired with tasty fries, earns high praise from many reviewers.
- 2Campagnola815 Chicago Ave
Salmon is frequently praised for its perfect cooking, freshness, and delicious pairing with lentils and greens.
- 3Prairie Moon1635 Chicago Ave
- 4Jilly's Cafe2614 Green Bay Rd
- 7Soul & Smoke1601 Payne St Ste C
- 8Tapas Barcelona1615 Chicago Ave
Tilapia is praised for its delicious flavor, often served with tasty mashed potatoes and spinach in a lemon sauce.
- 9Alcove - Evanston1625 Maple Ave
- 10Prairie Moon1635 Chicago Ave
- 11Union Pizzeria-Evanston1245 Chicago Ave
Salmon is consistently praised for its delicious flavor and is a must-try alongside the inviting atmosphere.
- 12Prairie Moon1635 Chicago Ave
- 13Oceanique505 Main St
Bouillabaisse features flavorful seafood and saffron aioli, though some found the broth too thick or lacking in authenticity.
- 14Campagnola815 Chicago Ave
Halibut is praised for its fresh flavor and perfect cooking, though some found it overcooked or lacking sauce.
- 15LeTour Kitchen & Bar625 Davis Street Orrington Plaza
Salmon is praised for its flavor and cooking, though some found it overdone, and portions were considered small.
- 16Trattoria Demi1571 Sherman Ave
- 18Evanston Chicken Shack1925 Ridge Ave
- 19Tapas Barcelona1615 Chicago Ave
- 21Campagnola815 Chicago Ave
Trout is often praised for its moistness and flavor, but some found it overly saucy or lacking in substance.
- 22The Barn Steakhouse1016 Church St Rear
Branzino is praised for its flavor and presentation, but some found it overpriced and criticized the accompanying sauce and sides.
- 23LeTour Kitchen & Bar625 Davis Street Orrington Plaza
Skate wing is praised for its melt-in-your-mouth texture and flavor, though some found it overcooked or lacking seasoning.
- 25Tapas Barcelona1615 Chicago Ave
Salmon is praised for its flavor and presentation, but some found it overcooked and not authentic to traditional tapas.
- 26The Barn Steakhouse1016 Church St Rear
- 27Tapas Barcelona1615 Chicago Ave
- 28
- 29Tapas Barcelona1615 Chicago Ave
Gambas al ajillo features tender garlic shrimp in olive oil, but some found it undercooked and lacking spice.
- 30Tapas Barcelona1615 Chicago Ave
Seafood paella features a good variety of seafood, but many found the rice too wet or overcooked.
- 31
- 32Trattoria Demi1571 Sherman Ave
- 33Evanston Chicken Shack1925 Ridge Ave
- 34Tapas Barcelona1615 Chicago Ave
Garlic shrimp portions are disappointingly small, with inconsistent flavor and texture, overshadowing the otherwise enjoyable dining experience.
- 35Prairie Moon1635 Chicago Ave
- 36The Barn Steakhouse1016 Church St Rear
The salmon often disappoints with dryness and undercooking, overshadowing its potential flavor and contributing to a lackluster dining experience.
- 37Alcove - Evanston1625 Maple Ave
- 38
- 39LeTour Kitchen & Bar625 Davis Street Orrington Plaza
- 40Valli Produce1910 Dempster St
The sushi suffers from inconsistent quality and poor preparation, with some rolls not being properly made or traditional.
- 41Tapas Barcelona1615 Chicago Ave
- 42The Barn Steakhouse1016 Church St Rear
Halibut was criticized for being overcooked, dry, and tasteless, leaving diners feeling disappointed and unsatisfied.
- 43Tapas Barcelona1615 Chicago Ave
The ceviche was criticized for being bland, poorly presented, and lacking the expected flavors of traditional ceviche.
- 44Trattoria D.O.C.706 Main St