Best Seafood in Evanston, IL

fish and chips

Celtic Knot Public House2022 Central St

Crispy fish with light breading and excellent cod, paired with tasty fries, earns high praise from many reviewers.

2

cedar plank salmon

Prairie Moon1635 Chicago Ave

3

sea bass

Oceanique505 Main St

4

salmon

Campagnola815 Chicago Ave

Salmon is frequently praised for its perfect cooking, freshness, and delicious pairing with lentils and greens.

5

sea bass

KANSAKU1514 Sherman Ave

6

bouillabaisse

Jilly's Cafe2614 Green Bay Rd

7

salmon

Soul & Smoke1601 Payne St Ste C

8

tilapia

Tapas Barcelona1615 Chicago Ave

Tilapia is praised for its delicious flavor, often served with tasty mashed potatoes and spinach in a lemon sauce.

9

salmon

Bluestone1932 Central St

10

salmon

Alcove - Evanston1625 Maple Ave

11

salmon

Prairie Moon1635 Chicago Ave

12

salmon

Union Pizzeria-Evanston1245 Chicago Ave

Salmon is consistently praised for its delicious flavor and is a must-try alongside the inviting atmosphere.

13

bouillabaisse

Oceanique505 Main St

Bouillabaisse features flavorful seafood and saffron aioli, though some found the broth too thick or lacking in authenticity.

14

trout

Prairie Moon1635 Chicago Ave

15

fried shrimp

Evanston Chicken Shack1925 Ridge Ave

16

salmon

LeTour Kitchen & Bar625 Davis Street Orrington Plaza

Salmon is praised for its flavor and cooking, though some found it overdone, and portions were considered small.

17

halibut

Campagnola815 Chicago Ave

Halibut is praised for its fresh flavor and perfect cooking, though some found it overcooked or lacking sauce.

18

skate

Oceanique505 Main St

19

grilled squid

Tapas Barcelona1615 Chicago Ave

20

salmon

Picnic1619 N Chicago Ave

21

cioppino

Trattoria Demi1571 Sherman Ave

22

ceviche

The Barn Steakhouse1016 Church St Rear

23

trout

Campagnola815 Chicago Ave

Trout is often praised for its moistness and flavor, but some found it overly saucy or lacking in substance.

24

branzino

The Barn Steakhouse1016 Church St Rear

Branzino is praised for its flavor and presentation, but some found it overpriced and criticized the accompanying sauce and sides.

25

skate wing

LeTour Kitchen & Bar625 Davis Street Orrington Plaza

Skate wing is praised for its melt-in-your-mouth texture and flavor, though some found it overcooked or lacking seasoning.

26

catfish

Fatzees1608 Emerson St

27

mejillones plancha

Tapas Barcelona1615 Chicago Ave

28

salmon con esparragos

Tapas Barcelona1615 Chicago Ave

29

salmon

The Barn Steakhouse1016 Church St Rear

The salmon often disappoints with dryness and undercooking, overshadowing its potential flavor and contributing to a lackluster dining experience.

30

salmon

Tapas Barcelona1615 Chicago Ave

Salmon is praised for its flavor and presentation, but some found it overcooked and not authentic to traditional tapas.

31

salmon

Trattoria Demi1571 Sherman Ave

32

shrimp

Prairie Moon1635 Chicago Ave

33

garlic shrimp

Tapas Barcelona1615 Chicago Ave

Garlic shrimp portions are disappointingly small, with inconsistent flavor and texture, overshadowing the otherwise enjoyable dining experience.

34

shrimp

Evanston Chicken Shack1925 Ridge Ave

35

seafood paella

Tapas Barcelona1615 Chicago Ave

Seafood paella features a good variety of seafood, but many found the rice too wet or overcooked.

36

halibut

Oceanique505 Main St

Halibut is well-cooked with good accompaniments, but many found it lacking flavor and criticized the portion size.

37

gambas al ajillo

Tapas Barcelona1615 Chicago Ave

Gambas al ajillo features tender garlic shrimp in olive oil, but some found it undercooked and lacking spice.

38

swordfish

Oceanique505 Main St

Swordfish is well-seared and flavorful, but some found it overcooked or tough, and seasoning was inconsistent.

39

monkfish

LeTour Kitchen & Bar625 Davis Street Orrington Plaza

40

halibut

Alcove - Evanston1625 Maple Ave

41

salmon

Oceanique505 Main St

The salmon often lacked flavor, was sometimes overcooked or mushy, and portions were considered small for the price.

42

sushi

Valli Produce1910 Dempster St

The sushi suffers from inconsistent quality and poor preparation, with some rolls not being properly made or traditional.

43

shrimp

Tapas Barcelona1615 Chicago Ave

44

halibut

The Barn Steakhouse1016 Church St Rear

Halibut was criticized for being overcooked, dry, and tasteless, leaving diners feeling disappointed and unsatisfied.

45

catalana paella

Tapas Barcelona1615 Chicago Ave

46

ceviche

Tapas Barcelona1615 Chicago Ave

The ceviche was criticized for being bland, poorly presented, and lacking the expected flavors of traditional ceviche.

47

sea bass

Trattoria D.O.C.706 Main St

Caprarius

Caprarius

Caprarius

Caprarius

Best Seafood in Evanston, IL

Which one is the GOAT?

More in Evanston, IL