Best Shakes & Malts in Hyde Park, Chicago
The 12 top-rated shakes & malts in Hyde Park, Chicago, ranked by flavor score.
The top choice is milkshakes (all varieties) at Medici On 57th (1327 E 57th St), with a flavor score of 90 out of 100 from 87 diner ratings. Flavor scores come from what real diners say in their reviews. Last updated August 27, 2026. How flavor scores work →
Best Shakes & Malts across Chicago→- Ranked #1At Medici On 57th1327 E 57th St
The Mexicana milkshake impresses with its rich chocolate flavor and hint of cinnamon, while the fudge banana nut shake delights with pecans.
- Ranked #2At Small Cheval- Hyde Park1307 E 53rd St Fl 1
Thick, creamy milkshakes with chunks of flavor are consistently praised for their deliciousness, especially the strawberry and salted caramel varieties.
- Ranked #3At Can't believe it's not meat1368 E 53rd St
The Cookie Monster shake impresses with its rich Oreo flavor and creamy texture, making it a standout favorite among patrons.
- Ranked #4At Medici On 57th1327 E 57th St
- Ranked #5At Small Cheval- Hyde Park1307 E 53rd St Fl 1
- Ranked #6At Sweet Drip1658 E 53rd St
- Ranked #7At Sip & Savor | 53rd Street - Hyde Park5301 S Hyde Park Blvd
- Ranked #8At Sip & Savor | 53rd Street - Hyde Park5301 S Hyde Park Blvd
- Ranked #9At Small Cheval- Hyde Park1307 E 53rd St Fl 1
- Ranked #10At Five Guys1456 E 53rd St
Milkshakes are thick but often flavorless, overpriced, and sometimes arrive late or even missing, disappointing many customers.